4 Forwards from SAFs reign.

Originally Posted by Zorg

I know - doesn't put him anywhere near the top four forwards in Fergie's time though does it, let's be honest.

Hughes
Cantona
RVN
RVP
Rooney
Cole
Yorke
Sheringham
Solskjaer
Forlan

All were/are better than McClair.

Maybe not forlan

Very good player, McClair. I think his contribution in transforming us from the crap we were to team we became is often overlooked. Wouldn't be in my top 4, but definitely worthy of consideration.

Hughes (my first hero, I want to hate him for being a @#%&! since but can't)
Cantona
RvN
Rooney

Cole for Hughes if you look at it objectively but it's subjective isn't it

Originally Posted by utd99

Very good player, McClair. I think his contribution in transforming us from the crap we were to team we became is often overlooked. Wouldn't be in my top 4, but definitely worthy of consideration.

This.

He was a bit of marmite player though. Plenty £#%&!ing loathed him.

Originally Posted by dunk

This.

He was a bit of marmite player though. Plenty £#%&!ing loathed him.

Eric loved him, watch his chip against Sunderland again, first thing he says is 'thanks chocky' (might be cheers chocky but I'm not youtubing it to check)

Originally Posted by utd99

Very good player, McClair. I think his contribution in transforming us from the crap we were to team we became is often overlooked. Wouldn't be in my top 4, but definitely worthy of consideration.

Loved chocolate. top striker. shit haircut. no wonder he wore a headband.

Forlan better than Mcclair for United? Ive heard it all now

Hirst
Shearer
kluivert
Salas

Originally Posted by Stickman

Forlan better than Mcclair for United? Ive heard it all now

That bit was a joke ffs.

The others are right though imo. I'm not saying McClair was shit, just that I can't see how he's even close to the top four forwards under Ferige.

Originally Posted by Zorg

That bit was a joke ffs.

The others are right though imo. I'm not saying McClair was shit, just that I can't see how he's even close to the top four forwards under Ferige.

Nowhere near the top four, but as someone else said, an important player in the 'formative' years between being shite and title contenders. He's not helped that he the one dropped up front for Eric who then went on to be the massive difference, therefore making McClair look like the problem

Originally Posted by The Return of JC

someone