Best Utd XI vs Other XI of the Premier League years

Who would win?

Best United (4-3-3)

Schmeichel

G Neville
Vidic
Rio
Irwin

Keane
Scholes
Pogba

Ronaldo
Rooney
Tevez

vs

OTHER XI (4-3-3)

Cech

Trent-Arnold
VVD
Kompany
A Cole

Vieira
De Bruyne
Gerard

Shearer
Aguero
Henry

A peak Shearer walks into that PL XI side over all the ones you picked. Just saying .

Was gonna reply and then i saw you'd stuck Pogba and Tevez in the Utd team...

Originally Posted by Arnold Muhren

A peak Shearer walks into that PL XI side over all the ones you picked. Just saying .

Shit.

Going to insert the Brent 'forgot about that' gif :-)

Originally Posted by Gypsum Fantastic

Was gonna reply and then i saw you'd stuck Pogba and Tevez in the Utd team...

Pogba replaced by .... Giggs? Carrick?


Tevez by...Giggs? Rashford? RVP? RVN? Not sure how they'd mesh with Rooney and Ronaldo

Nobody from the present team in the United XI, genuinely shocked.

Pogba wouldn’t get in over Butt let alone Beckham

pogba, tevez, gerard, kompany.....

Is Pogba in there as a joke? Terry over Kompany, RVN over Tevez and if you can’t find a place for Eric who was better than everyone across both squads then you should be shot dead.

Originally Posted by Chris Quayd

Is Pogba in there as a joke? Terry over Kompany, RVN over Tevez and if you can’t find a place for Eric who was better than everyone across both squads then you should be shot dead.

Harsh but actually fair.

Originally Posted by Chris Quayd

Is Pogba in there as a joke? Terry over Kompany, RVN over Tevez and if you can’t find a place for Eric who was better than everyone across both squads then you should be shot dead.

I love Eric but he wasn't better than Rooney, Ronaldo and Shearer.

Originally Posted by tatty

I love Eric but he wasn't better than Rooney, Ronaldo and Shearer.

At his best he surely was at least equal, but the others were all as good for longer.

Lampard not in? Most goals from midfield. No Tony Adams?

Vieira proved to be a coward up against Keane.

Pogba..what Paul Pogba?

Originally Posted by My Name is Heath

Shit.

Going to insert the Brent 'forgot about that' gif :-)







Pogba replaced by .... Giggs? Carrick?


Tevez by...Giggs? Rashford? RVP? RVN? Not sure how they'd mesh with Rooney and Ronaldo

To not have RVN or Giggs in is lunacy tbf. Get pogba and Tevez out for those two. If you want three in midfield, Ince is probably the man. An Ince-Keane-Scholes midfield would be frightening tbf

Any Utd side without

Robbo
Ruud
Cantona

Is utter lunacy .

I have spoken

Pogba in the best united XI during the last 28 years!?

For me the squad would be

Schmeichel
G.Nev
Vidic
Rio
Irwin
Ronaldo
Keane
Scholes
Giggs
Cantona
Ruud

Bench: VDS, Stam, Evra, Beckham, Carrick, Rooney, Cole

Originally Posted by Terry Truthman

Pogba in the best united XI during the last 28 years!?

For me the squad would be

Schmeichel
G.Nev
Vidic
Rio
Irwin
Ronaldo
Keane
Scholes
Giggs
Cantona
Ruud

Bench: VDS, Stam, Evra, Beckham, Carrick, Rooney, Cole

Pretty much bob on but I’d rather have Rashford than Cole on the bench.

Originally Posted by 92ToBury

Pretty much bob on but I’d rather have Rashford than Cole on the bench.

He's got someone to go before that, surely...

Consider the strikers we have had.

Originally Posted by Child of Darkness

Any Utd side without

Robbo
Ruud
Cantona

Is utter lunacy .

I have spoken

And you'd be right. Arguably Robbo wasn't at his best in the Premier League years but no Eric? Shooting is too good for this lunatic. An outrage.

Originally Posted by TravellingRed

And you'd be right. Arguably Robbo wasn't at his best in the Premier League years but no Eric? Shooting is too good for this lunatic. An outrage.

So you'd play 4-3-1-2 with Eric behind Ronaldo and Rooney?

I could live with that.

Pogba was a slight wum but it was legit him/Carrick/Ince/Giggs/Beckham for that creative midfield spot.

For the others...so many good players and i think the tight calls (Terry vs Kompany, Gerard vs Lampard etc.) are marginal.