The worst ever individual performance from a united player?

Originally Posted by TheFatGoth

Dortmund

Yup. Dortmund at home. Was at the game. Horrific performance and one which he said he knew his playing days were over...

Yeah, good call Dortmund, still shocking that they knocked us out

Paddy Roche in any of the games he played.
My labrador would have made a better keeper.

Gary Neville in the 1-3 at Maine Road.

Gary Neville at WBA

Originally Posted by dunk

Gary Neville in the 1-3 at Maine Road.

Gary Neville at WBA

Neville at West Brom sprung to my mind too.

There's bad because the player is shit, there's bad because the player is good but having an off day.... but being bad because you're finished is downright sad.

Neville at WBA was probably the best example of someone clearly being done in one half of football.

Lukaku vs City

Rooney had quite a few stinkers last going off.

Vidic against Torres.

Talking of cbs, probably a bit harsh as far as “worst ever” goes but Stam vs Anelka or Owen. Looked more impressive than he actually was imv. Fosu gets the same . Must be a Dutch thing.

Barthez v Arsenal

Originally Posted by woody78

Barthez v Arsenal

Originally Posted by windy waffles

Yup. Dortmund at home. Was at the game. Horrific performance and one which he said he knew his playing days were over...

Jurgen Kohler, lying on the line. Eric 2 yards out, hits it off his head

That tie still makes me mad, they scored 2 deflected goals, Utd missed about 30 clear chances. Giggs coming on in the last 20 with a pulled hammy and having 2 goals disallowed.

Eric bottling out of a tackle for their goal in the away leg was just a preview for his second leg performance.

Evans v West Ham or the Bebe crossing show.

Originally Posted by Albert Tatlock

Obertan is Marlo's mate intee ?

No idea. Size of head would suggest so.

Obertan had a game early in his United career (against Besiktas iirc) where he looked class. I would say it was only Besiktas but they won

Originally Posted by dunk

Gary Neville in the 1-3 at Maine Road.

Gary Neville at WBA

After Di María of course, Neville at West Brom next one that really stands out. He knew it as well.

That Bebe game with the crosses

Anto Whelan's one and only game. Came on as a sub for Kevin Moran and was that shit the United fans sang "Anto Anto you belong in a panto".

Taibi v Everton - wiping Denis out, leaving Poyet to score in the first minute iirc. Plus letting in another four in the same game.

Most of Zoran Tosic's 79 minutes for us.

Much of Kleberson's time with us too.

Still, I don't think any performance beats this:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kh6Uy-95U0g

Originally Posted by 92ToBury

Anto Whelan's one and only game. Came on as a sub for Kevin Moran and was that shit the United fans sang "Anto Anto you belong in a panto".

Taibi v Everton - wiping Denis out, leaving Poyet to score in the first minute iirc. Plus letting in another four in the same game.

Most of Zoran Tosic's 79 minutes for us.

Much of Kleberson's time with us too.

Still, I don't think any performance beats this:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kh6Uy-95U0g

No wonder Taibi was so bad against Everton. He was at Stamford bridge at the time.

Originally Posted by Albert Tatlock

He had a poor run when he first joined us. Our expectations were naturally high and he dashed them

Actually his first half season wasn't bad, it was in the latter part especially of the 1995/96 campaign when he really struggled - quite possibly *that* experience at West Ham set him back a bit.

Didn't Luke Chadwick come on as a 2nd half sub and then get subbed off 20 mins later vs Villa in FA cup around 2001? Back when we seemed to draw villa pretty much every season in the early rounds.

Massimo Taibi in every game he played.

Phil Jones for most of his United career

Sanchez. All the time

Originally Posted by Singy211291

Massimo Taibi in every game he played.

Didn't he have one good game for us, against the Vermin of all people?

Originally Posted by 92ToBury

Anto Whelan's one and only game.

Details please? The only Whelan I know played in the 60s.