PFA Player of the Year

Got to be van Persehole.

- that list. Surprised not to see Kompany or Evans on it. RVP should win it by a country mile; expect it to go to Muamba though.

van persie and Welbeck. Sounds about right

Scott Parker? Decent player but it shows how far the standards have fallen in the Pl when he is the stand out midfielder in the eyes of his fellow players.

De Gea should have been nominated for the young player award, but the media campaign against him, and a few high profile mistakes and it will take a while for him to build his reputation.

Van Persie easily wins this.

Originally Posted by wiganste

van persie and Welbeck. Sounds about right

Aguero Will get Young player. Even though he isn't young.

Originally Posted by Tiberian

De Gea should have been nominated for the young player award

And win it. tbf, it should be between him and the Arsenal keeper, they're pretty closely matched. But going by those nominated, Aguero pisses it.

Originally Posted by Blagger

- that list. Surprised not to see Kompany or Evans on it. RVP should win it by a country mile; expect it to go to Muamba though.

Evans should have been on it....defo

Hart saved cideh 2 points at Villa and 2 at Wigan. He was very good when the team was very good too, but even if he had played shit, they were still free-scoring enough to have dealt with it.

Now the defense has gone to shit, he is not so much struggling, but isn't bailing them out like he did in those two games.

Still deserves to be on there mind.

My shortlist would be Joe Allen, Joe Hart, RVP, Kompany, Krul, Ba, Tony V

YPoY (U21 for me) - Walker, Welbeck, AOC, De Gea

Originally Posted by bobbledinho

Like against Wigan last week?

Rooney doesn't win games the way Ronaldo could or the way RVP does. It's not his fault, he's given a role in the team and does it well.

But he's had better seasons and he can be much better. He hasn't been an outstanding individual this season.

they were all shit at Wigan and Rooney was only on for an hour

RVP and Aguero nailed on

Originally Posted by Tiberian

De Gea should have been nominated for the young player award, but the media campaign against him, and a few high profile mistakes and it will take a while for him to build his reputation.

Very good point. He's been brilliant for months now.

yaya toure should be the city nominee imo but van persie deserves it, no question.

should be between joe allen, welbeck and aguero for young player of the year.

Originally Posted by The Watcher

And win it. tbf, it should be between him and the Arsenal keeper, not much between them. But going by those nominated, Aguero pisses it.

They really need to look at their criteria for the young player award though. Players like Aguero who is an experienced international player, 23 years old, has been playing on the world stage for 4-5 years should not be listed. We had Rooney at 24 with 7 years top flight experience being nominated for this award as well, make it breakthrough players or under 21.

Yaya Toure is unfortunate not to be nominated for the main award, well ahead of Aguero in performances and importance.

Originally Posted by £#%&! KFC

they were all shit at Wigan and Rooney was only on for an hour

Strange that Fergie brought off our "match-winner" when we needed him most eh?

Originally Posted by bobbledinho

Strange that Fergie brought off our "match-winner" when we needed him most eh?

One of the less strange things about that night tbh

Originally Posted by bobbledinho

Strange that Fergie brought off our "match-winner" when we needed him most eh?

took him off yesterday as well didn't he....after he had WON us the match

Originally Posted by Rhodzy

Also Sparky, just shut up.

Originally Posted by saffers

He just hates our English players doesn't he.

He's gonna be bashing Youngie, Wazza, Welbz, Clevz, Jonesy all summer.

Only ones I haven't seen him castigate are Rio and Smallers, probably cos they're both cockney redz.

Originally Posted by Rhodzy

Spot on, southern muppet. :shakehead:

Originally Posted by elhombre

is anything ever good enough for sparky???

rooney scores goals... what more can you ask of him?

Originally Posted by Zorg

Very good point. He's been brilliant for months now.

these are voted for in january arent they? would explain it.

rvp and welbz

shocked joneseh hasn't been nominated

Originally Posted by Ginners

these are voted for in january arent they? would explain it.

Then why the £#%&! do they only announce the nominations now?