Rate our centre backs

1. Varane
2. Lindelof
3. Bailly
4. Jones
5. Maguire

Got to drop Slab if the others are fit.

Misread the title



1. Varane

Varane
Maguire
Bailly
Lindelof
Tuanzebe
Jones

No thank you.

Originally Posted by Gypsum Fantastic

1. Varane
2. Lindelof
3. Bailly
4. Jones
5. Maguire

Got to drop Slab if the others are fit.

Maguire is a good player when on form. When he's bad though, he's £#%&!ing horrific.

No

Varane 9/10
Lindelof 6/10
Bailly 7/10 (8-9 on a good day, 2 on a bad one.)
Jones 6/10
Maguire 7/10

Varane - crystal
Bailly - glass
Lindelof - cardboard
Jones - sponge
Maguire - concrete

Maguire is still our best.

Originally Posted by suedeshoes

Maguire is still our best.

at what? Surely you don't mean defending

Originally Posted by suedeshoes

Maguire is still our biggest waste of money.

Edited for accuracy

He's the best of the bunch at the moment. I haven't seen enough of Varane in red yet.

Varane
Maguire
Lindelof
Bailly

Originally Posted by Gypsum Fantastic

1. Varane
2. Lindelof
3. Bailly
4. Jones
5. Maguire

Got to drop Slab if the others are fit.

hard to rate, as they all have different weaknesses. lindelof is a @#%&!, but with a qb arm. bailly is mad. maguire is a bit of a slug sometimes. jones? £#%&! off.

on a good day, varane and bailly would be an excellent pairing, but, on an average day, it has to be varane and the maginot line.

Originally Posted by suedeshoes

Maguire is still our best.

...bet for saving mankind from an asteroid by using the gravitational pull of his head to deflect its path.

Originally Posted by armchair

Varane 9/10
Lindelof 6/10
Bailly 7/10 (8-9 on a good day, 2 on a bad one.)
Jones 6/10
Maguire 7/10

Jones surely has to play to get a rating?

in a world where being injured isnt a thing

1. Varane
2. Bailly
3. Maguire
4. Lindelof
5. Jones

Though Maguire is playing like he's #5 on that list this season.

Originally Posted by suedeshoes

Maguire is still our best.

Are you sure you have been watching the same, Harry Maguire as the rest of us? I guess we can only hope that he turns his , United career around a.s.a.p, for the sake of all our sanity's seeing as he is the Captain he needs too learn too lead by example & atm he is'nt doing that at all!

Originally Posted by Gypsum Fantastic

1. Varane
2. Lindelof
3. Bailly
4. Jones
5. Maguire

Got to drop Slab if the others are fit.

Stand by this. Maguire and Shaw should both have been dropped weeks ago. If you don't lose your place after these performances when do you?

Originally Posted by Gypsum Fantastic

Stand by this. Maguire and Shaw should both have been dropped weeks ago. If you don't lose your place after these performances when do you?

Because if you base this philosophy on the previous first eleven you’d have to make 8 or 9 changes.

Also, even if he had made the two changes you suggested he’d have still played the same formation because it worked once before. City out thought it after five minutes and we’re incapable of changing it.

What we’re doing now is looking for a new excuse every week to try and deflect the attention away from the management. One week it’s De Gea, then it’s Fred, then it’s Maguire and so on and so on.

The manager believes he’s so far in to a project that’s almost working that if he makes serious changes now it’s an admission of defeat. No manager is going to do that unfortunately.