Scholes and Giggs

can't be relied upon anymore. from now on if they aren't playing well they should be dropped. their reputation is the only thing keeping them in the side atm. nft.

Best seasons for years. One bad match . get rid.

Originally Posted by dodger

Best seasons for years. One bad match . get rid.

both outstanding for the first half of the season. both been bobbins for the last couple of months, imo. nft.

Diminishing returns against the better sides. Still good enough against most of the premiership and in home Euro matches, but if we want to maintain success next year and have a better chance of winning the EC they will need to be replaced, or at least have good alternatives.

Due to the lack of options they have had to play too many games and it has cut down on their effectiveness. Park and Saha missing has come at the worst time.

imo you are talking shite nft

Originally Posted by Yo Adrian!

imo you are talking shite nft

imo, you should be banned. nft.

Scholes = class
Giggs = rubbish

Originally Posted by Prideofalleurope

Scholes = class
Giggs = rubbish

a truly unbelievable statement

Originally Posted by El Calafate

can't be relied upon anymore. from now on if they aren't playing well they should be dropped. their reputation is the only thing keeping them in the side atm. nft.

is that Ryan Scholes and Paul Giggs ?

Originally Posted by denis lawless

is that Ryan Scholes and Paul Giggs ?

yes, in that order. nft.

Originally Posted by Smeggs

a truly unbelievable statement

I don't think hes up to it anymore. His passing and tackling is woeful.

Yep - Giggs was woeful against Roma at home wasn't he.

Scholes and Giggs have both been superb for us this season.

And without wanting to sound like that guy off Police Academy, for many, many, many others.


They will be class next season too.

the trouble with both is, that they are not going to get any better, but are steadily going to decline.

both are capable of turning in great performances, as both have done on many occasions this season.

the problem is that with age you slow down, and we haven't the squad available to ever really take them out, we need more cover for both. scholes has missed a few recently, but imo the damage physically was already done, and he has looked jaded since his suspension. that said he's still one of our better performers every week.

and as much as I love them both, we need hearts not to rule heads as they did with keane and fergie not to take 2 seasons to realise they are holding the others back, whenever that may be

El you continually piss me off to a mammoth degree with your sad, sad need to put nft at the end of everything you say (what normal person could actually be arsed to do that all the time??) but this is unbelievable.

Scholes in particular. Critically acclaimed by his peers and pundits a like all season and you come out with this.

Surely a WUM. If not seek help pronto or just top yer £#%&!ing self.

Originally Posted by Barca '91

El you continually piss me off to a mammoth degree with your sad, sad need to put nft at the end of everything you say (what normal person could actually be arsed to do that all the time??) but this is unbelievable.

Scholes in particular. Critically acclaimed by his peers and pundits a like all season and you come out with this.

Surely a WUM. If not seek help pronto or just top yer £#%&!ing self.

nft.

Originally Posted by Barca '91

El you continually piss me off to a mammoth degree with your sad, sad need to put nft at the end of everything you say (what normal person could actually be arsed to do that all the time??) but this is unbelievable.

Scholes in particular. Critically acclaimed by his peers and pundits a like all season and you come out with this.

Surely a WUM. If not seek help pronto or just top yer £#%&!ing self.

i speak the truth. Scholes has been poor recently and imo, he's over rated. nft.

Originally Posted by El Calafate

i speak the truth. Scholes has been poor recently and imo, he's over rated. nft.

thought he was one of a few that put the effort in against Milan.

He remains one of the most neat and best passers in the premiership.

nft.

£#%&!s sake.

Both had great seasons.

Ok Giggs really didn't turn up against Milan in both games but Rubbish is a but much.

We'd be £#%&!ing stuggling without them.

Make a judgement on Scholes based on how he plays against Chelsea in a week or so. We can then see if he is becoming a Flat Track Pony.

Also read this:
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/pages/liv...n_page_id=1779