Half this board would blame VDS for both of those goals

To be fair, I would for the first one.

Boooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo

vds would have let in about two freekicks before those shots

Point being, people only seem to notice 'saveable' goals when they go in our net.

Vidic's equaliser vs Benfica, for instance, was a shocking piece of goalkeeping.

Everything is relative. Our keeper is not the best, but is better than most.

VDS should have well saved Trabelsi's shot.

He's £#%&!ing shit,Fergie bring back Carrol

There has only ever been 4 brilliant goalkeepers in the history of the game.

Okay I'll bite...

Who are they?

Not directed at me but the answer is, lev yashin, gordon banks, steve 'oggy' ogrizovic, and peter schmeichel

No Neville Southall? Have a word

and Neville Southall

Originally Posted by Ether

No Neville Southall? Have a word

Good keeper but not in the top 4, was too fat. the correct 4 would all be able to compete today, fat nev wouldn't.

Neville is the best keeper i've ever seen, only put on weight towards the end of his career and was still unbelievable; pisses on Oggy anyway.

Would the other 4 be able to do a round on the bins at 6 in the morning though? Doubt it.

Pat jennings
Banks
schmeichel
and I'll let you squabble about the other one.

My point is we have a good 'keeper and that's all you can expect to have.

Paddy Roche anyone?

peter cech has the ability to be up there in a few years

Peter Shilton won Forest the European Cup and the English title. Southall was top drawer. Schmeichel of course. Jennings is up there, as are Maier and Banks. Anyone else?

Originally Posted by Tumescent Throb

Peter Shilton won Forest the European Cup and the English title. Southall was top drawer. Schmeichel of course. Jennings is up there, as are Maier and Banks. Anyone else?

Top-drawer keepers not yet mentioned:

Clemence, Jean-Marie Pfaff, Zoff, van Breukelen, Renat Dassayev, Buffon, Kahn, Zenga, Bonetti, Schumacher, Casillas, Coupet...

Southall is the best goalkeeper in history in my opinion.

Bryan Gunn deserves a mention too.

Originally Posted by Ether

Bryan Gunn deserves a mention too.

He was a good First Division keeper. If we're including the likes of him, you'd have an awfully long list: Steve Sutton, Erik Thorstvedt, Phil Parkes, Corrigan (!), Stefan Klos, Andoni Zubizaretta, Perruzi, etc.