YOUR Top 5 worst signings of the post-Fergie era

Originally Posted by shenwen

Same.
Sanchez has been a 300k a week disaster. But somewhere there you can see the player he once was/wants to be. It was the same with Falcao. However, Di Maria, as many have eloquently described, was just an absolute @#%&!. No other signing comes close.

He was a gutless little rat.

That final appearance as Hull was pathetic.

A worm of the highest order.

Anyone who doesn't have the Argie eunuch at 1 hasn't been paying attention.

Have we made 5 good signings since Fergie?

Fellaini
DI Maria
Schneiderlin
Darmian
Lukaku

No particular order.

Originally Posted by General Woundwort

Anyone who doesn't have the Argie eunuch at 1 hasn't been paying attention.

Have we made 5 good signings since Fergie?

Shaw
Pogba
Martial

Um....

Possibly Mata, Herrera....

Pretty sorry state of affairs.

5? every £#%&!ing signing post Fergie has been a disaster. Martial the most promising but still not worth the 50 odd million.

Originally Posted by Chorlton74

Di Maria by a mile.

Surprised there's no mention for Victor Valdes

Never given a chance to be fair.

Missed opportunity.

Not a single mention of Lindelof, says it all

Originally Posted by Chris Quayd

Not a single mention of Lindelof, says it all

He's been pretty good the past two games to be fair to him.

Two good games put him right up there in terms of best signings which says it all really.

Schweinsteiger
Fellaini
Di Maria
Darmian
Lingards contract

Originally Posted by Chorlton74

Di Maria by a mile.

Surprised there's no mention for Victor Valdes

The competition is far too strong for a third choice goalkeeper to make the list tbf.

There are guys who don't even come close to the top 5 who ten years ago would be seen as duds.

Martial, Shaw and Pogba (just) are the only three you'd probably make again. Maybe Mata. Out of, what, 20 buys?

Originally Posted by Vedder

5? every £#%&!ing signing post Fergie has been a disaster. Martial the most promising but still not worth the 50 odd million.

I was thinking the same

Originally Posted by dunk

5. Mata
4. Schneiderlin
3. Rojo
2. Di Maria
1. Falcao (if he counts) or Schweinsteiger and Sanchez

Just can’t trim it to 5

Mata???

Apart from all the goals and assists and sometimes looking like the only player with an ounce of class, yeah, shocking.

Originally Posted by Buck

Ronaldo has scored exactly 200 more goals than our leading scorer in that time

£#%&!ing hell, what an incredible (in every senses) stat

Originally Posted by magic_cantona

Mata???

Apart from all the goals and assists and sometimes looking like the only player with an ounce of class, yeah, shocking.

He's been our most overrated signing of the post Fergie's years for sure

Originally Posted by Ranier Wolfcastle

He's been our most overrated signing of the post Fergie's years for sure

He offers us hugs, though.

It's Fellaini by miles. At least with the others we thought, expected or hoped they may turn out to be good. We already knew Fellaini was a useless @#%&!.

Originally Posted by magic_cantona

Mata???

Apart from all the goals and assists and sometimes looking like the only player with an ounce of class, yeah, shocking.

Dreadful signing. Didn’t fit at all, whether he’s managed to produce on occasion or not. Also disappointed massively in terms of what most thought we were getting.

Originally Posted by dunk

Dreadful signing. Didn’t fit at all, whether he’s managed to produce on occasion or not. Also disappointed massively in terms of what most thought we were getting.

3 goals in all comps last season. Not really the scoring threat suggested either. Miles away from our worst players though imo. Just a bit of a letdown as you say.

Originally Posted by S/Side.Red

3 goals in all comps last season. Not really the scoring threat suggested either. Miles away from our worst players though imo. Just a bit of a letdown as you say.

Nowhere near being our worst signing. Like has been said, the competition is huge.

Originally Posted by My Name is Keith

Nowhere near being our worst signing. Like has been said, the competition is huge.

In terms of price and profile, right up there tbh.