What's our current strongest XI?

Tbh, I knew there would be a lot of tinkering at the start of the season, but I (perhaps too optimistically) expected that we'd have some idea of our strongest XI by now. With the City game coming up I'd like to think (again, perhaps with too much optimism) that Fergie will play said best side.

Anyway, what do you lot think our strongest current XI looks like?

I reckon it's probably something like a 4-4-2, with one winger.

-------------------- De Gea ------------------
---- Rafael ---- Evans --- Rio ----- Evra----
------------ Anderson -- Carrick ------------
---- Valencia ---------------- Cleverley -----
-------------- RVP ------ Rooney ------------

DDG

Rafael Rio Evans Evra

Carrick

Anderson Cleverley

Rooney

Welbeck RVP

Not them £#%&!ers that started today

as long as Sir Mother£#%&!er doesnt pick it, thats the strongest

Ideally, with everyone fit I would say

DDG

Rafael-Evans-Vidic-Evra

Carrick-Anderson

Nani-Kagawa-Rooney

Van Persie

CB is difficult, I like Smalling but he has one major mistake a match in him, Rio is still very classy but his pace is gone.

No idea what to expect going into the city game, could be any line up.

de gea
rafael rio vidic evra i suppose
carrick
anderson cleverly
kagawa
rooney rvp

First off I'm loving the fact that everyone believes DDG to be the #1 keeper

Here goes

DDG

Rafael Jones Vidic Buttner

Valencia Carrick Kagawa Nani



Rooney RVP

Originally Posted by Tiberian

Ideally, with everyone fit I would say

DDG

Rafael-Evans-Vidic-Evra

Carrick-Anderson

Nani-Kagawa-Rooney

Van Persie

Current United players only pal.

£#%&! knows, it depends who we're playing and who's in and out of form. it doesn't have giggs, scholes or young in it, that's for sure.

just one mobile, energetic, physically dominant midfielder would transform this side. just one.

Originally Posted by Stone Monkey

First off I'm loving the fact that everyone believes DDG to be the #1 keeper

Here goes

DDG

Rafael Jones Vidic Buttner

Valencia Carrick Kagawa Nani



Rooney RVP

Lolz

Originally Posted by Stone Monkey

First off I'm loving the fact that everyone believes DDG to be the #1 keeper

Here goes

DDG

Rafael Jones Vidic Buttner

Valencia Carrick Kagawa Nani


Rooney RVP

don't you think it's bad enough watching us as it is

It's almost impossible to state our best starting XI because it has to include players that can not maintain any form of consistency Anderson, for example. He should be everyone's best XI based on what he should do but in all reality does anyone seriously believe he'll build on his cameo yesterday? I wish it could be true but I'm less than confident.

FWIW

De Gea
Rafael - Rio - Vidic - Evra
Carrick - Anderson
Valencia - Rooney - Nani
RVP

When everyone is fit

-------De Gea
Rafael-Rio-Vidic-Evra
----Carrick-Ando
Nani--Rooney-Kagawa
--------RvP

Originally Posted by saffers

When everyone is fit

-------De Gea
Rafael-Rio-Vidic-Evra
----Carrick-Ando
Nani--Rooney-Kagawa
--------RvP

ffs forgout about this @#%&!. this team.

Originally Posted by borsuk

£#%&! knows, it depends who we're playing and who's in and out of form. it doesn't have giggs, scholes or young in it, that's for sure.

just one mobile, energetic, physically dominant midfielder would transform this side. just one.

Originally Posted by borsuk

£#%&! knows, it depends who we're playing and who's in and out of form. it doesn't have giggs, scholes or young in it, that's for sure.

just one mobile, energetic, physically dominant midfielder would transform this side. just one.

if arse flop this season, which it looks like they will, Wiltshire has got to have his 'thinking about his future' cap on, surely a real effort to sign him. no one else in the PL particularly stands out.

Originally Posted by TripDownMiseryLane

if arse flop this season, which it looks like they will, Wiltshire has got to have his 'thinking about his future' cap on, surely a real effort to sign him. no one else in the PL particularly stands out.

fellaini or sandro would do me. that yacob at west brom is alright.

Originally Posted by borsuk

fellaini or sandro would do me. that yacob at west brom is alright.

All 'good' pro's but is that what we need? Young looked 'good' at villa. I Like Felaini, just don't think he's worldy classy enough for what we need.

-------De Gea
Rafael-Evans-Vidic-Evra
----Carrick-Cleverley
Nani--Rooney-Kagawa
--------RvP

Bench

Jones
Smalling
Anderson
Valencia
Welbeck
Hernandez
Lindegard

That's it right there, everyone fit

No Scholes, Giggs or Rio, sadly, definitely no Ashley £#%&!ing Young.

Depending on how Vidic is when he returns, Smalling to take over..

Originally Posted by dunk

-------De Gea
Rafael-Evans-Vidic-Evra
----Carrick-Cleverley
Nani--Rooney-Kagawa
--------RvP

Bench

Jones
Smalling
Anderson
Valencia
Welbeck
Hernandez
Lindegard

That's it right there, everyone fit

No Scholes, Giggs or Rio, sadly, definitely no Ashley £#%&!ing Young.

Depending on how Vidic is when he returns, Smalling to take over..

I'd swap Scholes for Lindegard.

Originally Posted by believe

I'd swap Scholes for Lindegard.

I wouldn't fancy Scholesy in nets tbh.

Missed Powell off, he needs shoehorning in somewhere, LB maybe..