Player Ratings - United v Sunderland, 5/10/2013

Starting XI:
de Gea -
Rafael -
Jones -
Vidic -
Evra -
Nani -
Carrick -
Cleverley -
Janujaz -
Rooney -
Robin van Persie -

Subs:
Welbeck -
Valencia -
Smalling -

Starting XI:
de Gea -7.5
Rafael -7
Jones -6.5
Vidic -6.5
Evra -6.5
Nani -7
Carrick -6.5
Cleverley -6.5
Janujaz -9
Rooney -3.1
Robin van Persie -6

Originally Posted by Aman27deep

Starting XI:
de Gea - 8
Rafael - 7
Jones - 6
Vidic - 6
Evra -7
Nani -7
Carrick - 8
Cleverley - 7
Janujaz - 10
Rooney - 5
Robin van Persie - 5

de Gea - 8 (without his crucial saves we would have lost this match)
Rafael - 7 (how good it is to have a proper right back)
Jones - 6 (nervous but better than his partner)
Vidic - 5 (woeful defensively)
Evra - 6
Nani - 6
Carrick - 6
Cleverley - 5
Janujaz - 8 (superb)
Rooney - 5 (along with vidic, worst united player on the pitch)
Robin van Persie - 6 (Poor yet again but at least his hold up play is still good)

de Gea - 7
Rafael - 8
Jones - 6
Vidic - 6
Evra - 6
Nani - 7
Carrick - 7
Cleverley - 7
Janujaz - 9 MOM
Rooney - 6
Robin van Persie - 6

Subs:
Welbeck - 5
Valencia - 5
Smalling - 5

Starting XI:
de Gea - 8
Rafael - 6.5
Jones - 5.5
Vidic - 5
Evra - 6
Nani - 6.5
Carrick - 6.5
Cleverley - 5.5
Janujaz - 9
Rooney - 3.5
Robin van Persie - 5

Subs:
Welbeck - 6
Valencia - 5.5
Smalling - 6

Originally Posted by Aman27deep

Starting XI:
de Gea - 7
Rafael - 7
Jones - 6
Vidic - 6
Evra - 6
Nani - 5
Carrick - 6
Cleverley - 6
Janujaz - 9
Rooney - 4 :shakehead:
Robin van Persie - 5

Subs:
Welbeck - 6
Valencia - 6
Smalling - n/a

DDG - 7
Januzaj - 8

£#%&! the rest.

Originally Posted by Aman27deep

Starting XI:
de Gea - 8
Rafael - 0
Jones -0
Vidic - 0
Evra - 0
Nani - 1
Carrick -1
Cleverley - 0
Janujaz -9
Rooney - -1
Robin van Persie - -2

Subs:
Welbeck -
Valencia -
Smalling -

Starting XI:
de Gea - 8. Immense.
Rafael - 8. Best right back playing in England.
Jones - 7.
Vidic - 5. Didn't have his best game tonight.
Evra - 6. At fault for the first goal but his attacking game was good.
Nani - 8.
Carrick - 7.
Cleverley - 6.
Janujaz - 9. We're spending £120k a week on Young, this is the person who deserves it.
Rooney - 5.
Robin van Persie - 5.

Subs:
Welbeck - 5.
Valencia - 7. Should've had an assist but didn't due poor finishing.
Smalling - 6.

Adnan gets a 10, surely? Best player on the pitch and match-winner with a worldy strike on his debut at 18? What more do you want?

Originally Posted by Aman27deep

Starting XI:
de Gea - 8. Immense.
Rafael - 8. Best right back playing in England.
Jones - 7.
Vidic - 5. Didn't have his best game tonight.
Evra - 6. At fault for the first goal but his attacking game was good.
Nani - 8.
Carrick - 7.
Cleverley - 6.
Janujaz - 9. We're spending £120k a week on Young, this is the person who deserves it.
Rooney - 5.
Robin van Persie - 5.

Subs:
Welbeck - 5.
Valencia - 7. Should've had an assist but didn't due poor finishing.
Smalling - 6.

Nani played a big part in the winner, tbf. Always trying to make things happen.

de Gea - 8/10
Rafael - 6/10
Jones - 7/10
Vidic - 5/10
Evra - 5/10
Nani - 6/10
Carrick - 6/10
Cleverley - 5/10
Janujaz - 10/10
Rooney - 6/10
Robin van Persie - 5/10

Only Nani and Januzaj did anything of attacking note in the game. So yes, an 8 from me for Nani.

Originally Posted by S/Side.Red

Adnan gets a 10, surely? Best player on the pitch and match-winner with a worldy strike on his debut at 18? What more do you want?

Not to dive.

De Gea 8
Rafael 7
Jones 6.5
Vidic 5.5
Evra 5
Nani 7
Carrick 6.5
Cleverley 7
Januzaj 9
Rooney 3.5
Van persie 4.5

Subs

Smalling 5.5
Welbeck 5.5
Valencia 6

Originally Posted by Chipsauce

Not to dive.

Yeah, he deserves a point knocked off for that

Originally Posted by Aman27deep

Starting XI:
de Gea - 9, for THAT save
Rafael - 7
Jones - 6.5
Vidic - 6
Evra - 6
Nani - 5
Carrick - 8
Cleverley - 7
Janujaz - 9.5
Rooney - 5
Robin van Persie - 5.5

Subs:
Welbeck - 7
Valencia - 6
Smalling - n/a

It's all about the brilliant Belgian

Originally Posted by red in cumbria

Yeah, he deserves a point knocked off for that

Like £#%&! If that's not a 10/10 I don't know what is. Match-winner on his debut. And the winning goal :mmmonkey: