Player Ratings - United v Liverpool (H), 25/09/2013

Dave - 7
Rafael -7
Evans- 8
Smalling - 7
Buttner -7
Nani - 7
Giggs - 6
Jones - 6.5
Kagawa - 6.5
Hernandez - 8
Rooney - 9

Subs

Carrick - 6
Januzaj - 7
Welbeck - 6

Starting XI:
de Gea - 7
Rafael - 6
Smalling - 5
Evans - 6
Buttner - 6
Nani - 7
Jones - 6
Giggs - 5
Kagawa - 6
Rooney - 8
Chicharito - 7

Substitutes -
Carrick - 6
Janujaz - 6
Welbeck - n/a

Not bad tbf.

why does it always have to be marks out of 10

you've got the entire range of numbers to choose from and yet everyone always chooses £#%&!ing 10



I'll give De Gea 78.4% out of 12,156/4

thought all the rest were about the same as well

Originally Posted by Bunker Buster

Yes he did defend well, was on rat face straight away with blocks and crunching tackles, tracked back, got forward, loads of link up play, fitness was good...

What more do you wAnt from left back with very little game time.

He made a few mistakes but he's decent cover, plays with a smile and always puts a shift in.

Decent player...

I'll surely pay more attention to his game now. Love players who care about our team and play with a smile.

Originally Posted by Jethro

And he made two good saves

If he didn't/couldn't stop a ball coming from a header onto his chest then maybe it's time to search for a new profession. And as I said the other save was good.

Originally Posted by Tumescent Throb

why does it always have to be marks out of 10

you've got the entire range of numbers to choose from and yet everyone always chooses £#%&!ing 10



I'll give De Gea 78.4% out of 12,156/4

thought all the rest were about the same as well

S.I unit of 'player rating ' though....

Was reading 'cracked' album reviews at the weekend they were out of 20

Enjoyed it.,

Unlike this...

Originally Posted by Tumescent Throb

why does it always have to be marks out of 10

you've got the entire range of numbers to choose from and yet everyone always chooses £#%&!ing 10



I'll give De Gea 78.4% out of 12,156/4

thought all the rest were about the same as well

Change your name to Hipster Throb.

Originally Posted by Tumescent Throb

why does it always have to be marks out of 10

you've got the entire range of numbers to choose from and yet everyone always chooses £#%&!ing 10



I'll give De Gea 78.4% out of 12,156/4

thought all the rest were about the same as well

aman didn't stipulate what units you had to use. it's hard to believe but I'm starting to think you may be some sort of contrarian

Originally Posted by Aman27deep

Starting XI:
de Gea - 7
Rafael - 7
Smalling - 7
Evans - 7
Buttner - 7
Nani - 6
Jones -6
Giggs -4
Kagawa - 6
Rooney - 8
Chicharito - 7

Substitutes -
Carrick - 6
Janujaz - 6
Welbeck -n/a

Overall pretty solid. A better performance than we had any right to expect with Giggs and Jones as our central pairing tbh.

Originally Posted by armchair

aman didn't stipulate what units you had to use. it's hard to believe but I'm starting to think you may be some sort of contrarian

tbf i haven't seen his post

de gea made two saves and the only player who was really disappointing (one turn aside) was kagawa.

rafael, giggs and rooney have 7. everyone else a solid 6. kagawa 5.

love rafael bringing the ball forward.

de Gea -7 -Did nothing wrong and a couple of good saves
Rafael - 7- some great runs out of defense
Smalling -7- better at CB than RB
Evans - 6- One or two errors but not had much football
Buttner -7 -Looked solid and was good on the break
Nani - 6- nice to have him back needs games
Jones - 8- Immense shielded the defence brilliantly MoTM for me
Giggs - 7 -Did well on the whole, added some imagination
Kagawa - 6- Flashes of promise but largely peripheral. Not a winger needs to be central
Rooney -8- Worked like a beast. Ran Jones close for MOTM
Chicharito -7 - Gets better all the time great movement and some good passing as well as a good goal
Exciting open game, enjoyed it

Starting XI:
de Gea - 9
Rafael - 9
Smalling - 7 (thought he was extremely sloppy early on)
Evans - 7
Buttner - 6
Nani - 8
Jones - 7
Giggs - 7 (should really be a 5 but as Tyler said, he gets special treatment for being a legend)
Kagawa - 7 (disappointing but not necessarily entirely his fault)
Rooney - 9 (superb. I want to hate him but he's been our best player so far this season)
Chicharito -7 (cracking goal but otherwise fairly quiet?)

Substitutes -
Carrick - 6
Janujaz - 8
Welbeck - 6

de Gea -6 -Not much work apart from a good save although moyes header was straight at him.
Rafael - 8 - finally a proper RB
Smalling -6- better at CB than RB, but very poor with the ball.
Evans - 6 - easily bullied
Buttner -6 - competent
Nani - 6- frustrating, but better than young
Jones - 7 - did well but poor in challenges.
Giggs - 5 - why is he still playing?
Kagawa - 6 - too weak on the ball.
Rooney - 7- Good.
Chicharito -8 - Great whenever he had the ball

Originally Posted by rafabio

de Gea -6 -Not much work apart from a good save although moyes header was straight at him.
Rafael - 8 - finally a proper RB
Smalling -6- better at CB than RB, but very poor with the ball.
Evans - 6 - easily bullied
Buttner -6 - competent
Nani - 6- frustrating, but better than young
Jones - 7 - did well but poor in challenges.
Giggs - 5 - why is he still playing?
Kagawa - 6 - too weak on the ball.
Rooney - 7- Good.
Chicharito -8 - Great whenever he had the ball

'Good'?

Should have been motm imo.

Good... :shakehead:

Originally Posted by Scabs

'Good'?

Should have been motm imo.

Good... :shakehead:

Yeah that's the only thing wrong with that post

Load of £#%&!ing %@#$&!s. All of it.

Originally Posted by rafabio

de Gea -6 -Not much work apart from a good save although moyes header was straight at him.
Rafael - 8 - finally a proper RB
Smalling -6- better at CB than RB, but very poor with the ball.
Evans - 6 - easily bullied
Buttner -6 - competent
Nani - 6- frustrating, but better than young
Jones - 7 - did well but poor in challenges.
Giggs - 5 - why is he still playing?
Kagawa - 6 - too weak on the ball.
Rooney - 7- Good.
Chicharito -8 - Great whenever he had the ball

What a £#%&!ing shit stain you are, stupid bastard.

Lot of negative scores here :shakehead: Thought they played quite well.

Didn't watch it so I'll base my scores on what I read and who I like.

de Gea - 8
Rafael - 9
Smalling - 6
Evans - 7
Buttner - 5
Nani - 7
Jones - 6
Giggs - 5
Kagawa - 2
Rooney - 12
Chicharito - 7

Substitutes -
Carrick - 7
Janujaz - 5
Welbeck -4

Look at the movement on this

Little £#%&!er must be an absolute nightmare to mark, for this alone he gets a 10

http://s3.amazonaws.com/br-cdn/temp_...0e3147a3_o.gif

Originally Posted by TC23 Henchasaurus

Look at the movement on this

Little £#%&!er must be an absolute nightmare to mark, for this alone he gets a 10

http://s3.amazonaws.com/br-cdn/temp_...0e3147a3_o.gif