Player Ratings - United v Liverpool (H), 25/09/2013

Starting XI:
de Gea -
Rafael -
Smalling -
Evans -
Buttner -
Nani -
Jones -
Giggs -
Kagawa -
Rooney -
Chicharito -

Substitutes -
Carrick -
Janujaz -
Welbeck -

Originally Posted by Aman27deep

Starting XI:
de Gea -7
Rafael -7
Smalling -7
Evans -7
Buttner -7
Nani -7
Jones -7
Giggs -7
Kagawa -7
Rooney -7
Chicharito -7

Substitutes -
Carrick -
Janujaz -
Welbeck -10

Originally Posted by Aman27deep

Starting XI:
de Gea -8
Rafael -8
Smalling -7
Evans -7
Buttner -5
Nani -6
Jones -6
Giggs -6
Kagawa -7
Rooney -9.95
Chicharito - 8

Substitutes -
Carrick -
Janujaz -
Welbeck -

...

Originally Posted by Aman27deep

Starting XI:
de Gea - 7
Rafael - 7
Smalling - 7
Evans - 7
Buttner - 7
Nani - 7
Jones - 6
Giggs - 6
Kagawa - 7
Rooney - 8
Chicharito - 7

Substitutes -
Carrick - 6
Janujaz - 6
Welbeck - 6

Starting XI:
de Gea - 6. One good save.
Rafael - 7. Lovely to have him back.
Smalling - 7. Obviously he's not a RB. Good to see him at CB made one mistake all game.
Evans - 6. Prone to mistakes.
Buttner - 4. Liability.
Nani - 7. Lovely to have a winger it the starting XI. Needs 50 games this season.
Jones - 6. Never a midfielder but he did a job. Too many reckless fouls though. Rat-face could've scored.
Giggs - 4. Do a RedNev.
Kagawa - 6. Needs to be more sharp.
Rooney - 9. MoM and our best player. No question he hates Liverpool as much as us. Immense.
Chicharito - 8. Born goal scorer.

Substitutes -
Carrick -
Janujaz -
Welbeck -

Buttner played well....

FFs aman try watching the game,

Won't be involved in this stat disgrace after that bombshell..

Originally Posted by Aman27deep

Starting XI:
de Gea - 6. One good save.

So 100% save rate, where did he lose the 4 points?

Originally Posted by Aman27deep

Starting XI:
de Gea - 7
Rafael - 7
Smalling -7
Evans - 7
Buttner - 6
Nani - 7
Jones - 7
Giggs - 6
Kagawa - 7
Rooney - 9
Chicharito - 8

Substitutes -
Carrick -
Janujaz -
Welbeck -

Not great but much better than the shite we have been served up so far this season.

Originally Posted by Aman27deep

Starting XI:
de Gea -7
Rafael -7
Smalling -6
Evans - 6
Buttner - 5
Nani - 7
Jones - 7
Giggs - 5
Kagawa - 7
Rooney - 8
Chicharito - 7

Substitutes -
Carrick - 6
Janujaz - 6
Welbeck 9 -

Originally Posted by Bunker Buster

Buttner played well....

FFs aman try watching the game,

Won't be involved in this stat disgrace after that bombshell..

Did he really defend well? Drifts off all the time. Has a bad first touch as well. Passing poor as well.


I don't think he's a left back. He should play LW ahead of Young.

Originally Posted by armchair

So 100% save rate, where did he lose the 4 points?

Didn't have his skills tested. That's to our defense's credit. Nothing againat de Gea. If a goalkeeper has his skills tested that means the defense didn't do his job.

Originally Posted by Aman27deep

Did he really defend well? Drifts off all the time. Has a bad first touch as well. Passing poor as well.


I don't think he's a left back. He should play LW ahead of Young.



Didn't have his skills tested. That's to our defense's credit. Nothing againat de Gea. If a goalkeeper has his skills tested that means the defense didn't do his job.

He made a blinding near post save and one from a Moses diving header

Originally Posted by Aman27deep

Did he really defend well? Drifts off all the time. Has a bad first touch as well. Passing poor as well.


I don't think he's a left back. He should play LW ahead of Young.



Didn't have his skills tested. That's to our defense's credit. Nothing againat de Gea. If a goalkeeper has his skills tested that means the defense didn't do his job.

so to get a high score a keeper has to play behind a bad defence and make a load of saves?

Originally Posted by Jethro

He made a blinding near post save and one from a Moses diving header

If you read my numbers i said he made one good save, and why are you commenting if you think this is a 'red cafe' thread?

Originally Posted by Aman27deep

If you read my numbers i said he made one good save, and why are you commenting if you think this is a 'red cafe' thread?

Because I'd like to join in a post match discussion. And he made two good saves

Starting XI:
de Gea - 7
Rafael - 8
Smalling - 6
Evans - 7
Buttner - 7
Nani - 8
Jones - 6
Giggs - 6
Kagawa - 7
Rooney - 9
Chicharito -8

Substitutes -
Carrick - 6
Janujaz - 7
Welbeck - 6

I'm giving Jones a seven

The rest were pretty good

de Gea - 7
Rafael -7
Smalling -7
Evans -7
Buttner -7
Nani -7
Jones -7
Giggs -6
Kagawa -6
Rooney -8.5
Chicharito -8

Substitutes -
Carrick -
Janujaz -
Welbeck -[/quote]

Originally Posted by Aman27deep

Did he really defend well? Drifts off all the time. Has a bad first touch as well. Passing poor as well.


I don't think he's a left back. He should play LW ahead of Young.



Didn't have his skills tested. That's to our defense's credit. Nothing againat de Gea. If a goalkeeper has his skills tested that means the defense didn't do his job.

Yes he did defend well, was on rat face straight away with blocks and crunching tackles, tracked back, got forward, loads of link up play, fitness was good...

What more do you wAnt from left back with very little game time.

He made a few mistakes but he's decent cover, plays with a smile and always puts a shift in.

Decent player...

de Gea -8
Rafael -8
Smalling -7
Evans -7
Buttner -7
Nani -7
Jones -6
Giggs -6
Kagawa -7
Rooney -8
Chicharito -8


Carrick -7
Janujaz -7
Welbeck -

Originally Posted by Bunker Buster

Yes he did defend well, was on rat face straight away with blocks and crunching tackles, tracked back, got forward, loads of link up play, fitness was good...

What more do you wAnt from left back with very little game time.

He made a few mistakes but he's decent cover, plays with a smile and always puts a shift in.

Decent player...

Must admit I hadn't noticed, will increase his mark.