Player Ratings - United v Liverpool (H), 25/09/2013

Originally Posted by rafabio

de Gea -6 -Not much work apart from a good save although moyes header was straight at him.

Refuses to sign Thiago, leads us to defeats at the Etihad and Anfield, and is now playing up-front for the Vermin. :shakehead:

Moyes Out!

Originally Posted by rafabio

de Gea -6 -Not much work apart from a good save although moyes header was straight at him.
Rafael - 8 - finally a proper RB
Smalling -6- better at CB than RB, but very poor with the ball.
Evans - 6 - easily bullied
Buttner -6 - competent
Nani - 6- frustrating, but better than young
Jones - 7 - did well but poor in challenges.
Giggs - 5 - why is he still playing?
Kagawa - 6 - too weak on the ball.
Rooney - 7- Good.
Chicharito -8 - Great whenever he had the ball

Jesus wept. Those comments ffs. :£#%&!er:

Originally Posted by dragflick

Jesus wept. Those comments ffs. :£#%&!er:

Proper #@&%! (him not you)

Originally Posted by ScholesScoresGoals2

Proper #@&%! (him not you)

Both tbf.

Originally Posted by dragflick

Both tbf.

this

should be moses

Yeah, we had guessed that. Somewhat unfortunate typo, nonetheless

Originally Posted by Aman27deep

Starting XI:
de Gea - 9
Rafael - 8
Smalling - 7
Evans - 7
Buttner - 7
Nani - 8
Jones - 8
Giggs - 7
Kagawa - 7
Rooney - 9
Chicharito - 9

Substitutes -
Carrick - 6
Janujaz - 6
Welbeck - N/A

I like Smalling as a CB. He is horribly one footed at times though.

Starting XI:
de Gea - 7
Rafael - 8
Smalling - 7
Evans - 9
Buttner - 7
Nani - 7
Jones - 7
Giggs - 7
Kagawa - 6
Rooney - 9
Chicharito - 8

Substitutes -
Carrick - 7
Janujaz - 6
Welbeck - N/A

Originally Posted by dunk

I like Smalling as a CB. He is horribly one footed at times though.

Starting XI:
de Gea - 7
Rafael - 8
Smalling - 7
Evans - 9
Buttner - 7
Nani - 7
Jones - 7
Giggs - 7
Kagawa - 6
Rooney - 9
Chicharito - 8

Substitutes -
Carrick - 7
Janujaz - 6
Welbeck - N/A

Thought he played well against Leverkusen at RB

Either way he's been really poor for a while now, a couple of decent performances this week from him so hopefully he'll kick on now.

Rafabio's comment on Evans.

It's like he doesn't watch the game then just repeats what he has seen someone say about said player in the past.

Originally Posted by Martin Tyler

de Gea -6 -Not much work apart from a good save although moyes header was straight at him.
Rafael - 8 - finally a proper RB
Smalling -6- better at CB than RB, but very poor with the ball.
Evans - 6 - easily bullied
Buttner -6 - competent
Nani - 6- frustrating, but better than young
Jones - 7 - did well but poor in challenges.
Giggs - 5 - why is he still playing?
Kagawa - 6 - too weak on the ball.
Rooney - 7- Good.
Chicharito -8 - Great whenever he had the ball

Originally Posted by That Boy Ronaldo!

Thought he played well against Leverkusen at RB

Either way he's been really poor for a while now, a couple of decent performances this week from him so hopefully he'll kick on now.

He did, but they were £#%&!ing £#%&!.

Chich's all round play is improving. Especially linking up on the counter attack

Originally Posted by TheKitchenSink

Originally Posted by silv

Chich's all round play is improving. Especially linking up on the counter attack

I'd be really devastated if he left cause of Welbeck.

Originally Posted by That Boy Ronaldo!

Thought he played well against Leverkusen at RB

Either way he's been really poor for a while now, a couple of decent performances this week from him so hopefully he'll kick on now.

being played out of position and exposed 2 v 1 constantly will fry your confidence. he needs a run at cb with a proper midfield.

Originally Posted by Aman27deep

Did he really defend well? Drifts off all the time. Has a bad first touch as well. Passing poor as well.


I don't think he's a left back. He should play LW ahead of Young.



Didn't have his skills tested. That's to our defense's credit. Nothing againat de Gea. If a goalkeeper has his skills tested that means the defense didn't do his job.

That's fairly good point your making tbh