Would Hernandez have scored as many as RVP?

Originally Posted by Bernard

16 in 20 starts inst bad by anyones standards?

How many when he's actually started?

Oh, and £#%&! you all. Like I give a £#%&!.

Hernandez is a great sub. Average starter. He may improve, we shall see. We shouldn't sell him and he'd be stupid to leave.

He's got 30 in 46 apps for Mexico, presumably most as a starter and plenty against half-decent opposition no doubt. According to MotD last night United only have 6 goals by substitutes this season in the league.

If Hernandez is more effective as a sub that will be to do with fresh legs obviously, but also to do with the fact that quite often his arrival signals a change in tactics as well - maybe the usual starting tactics are what reduces Hernandez' potential effect? Maybe a more quick-passing style (Kagawa running the show ) would suit him more?

Originally Posted by Tumescent Throb

He's got 30 in 46 apps for Mexico, presumably most as a starter and plenty against half-decent opposition no doubt. According to MotD last night United only have 6 goals by substitutes this season in the league.

If Hernandez is more effective as a sub that will be to do with fresh legs obviously, but also to do with the fact that quite often his arrival signals a change in tactics as well - maybe the usual starting tactics are what reduces Hernandez' potential effect? Maybe a more quick-passing style (Kagawa running the show ) would suit him more?

Quite possibly. That would open up a whole plethora of other questions about Fraggle's stubborn £#%&!ing tactics and whether we would be far too lightweight though.

I like Hernandez, top lad, loves a goal and works his %@#$&!s off, but I'm long since past hero worship, I have to call it as I see it, and goals or not, United always look weaker as a whole with him in the team, maybe as a result of the tactics, maybe as a result of the application of the tactics or the form/weaknesses in the team, but as it stands, I wouldn't pick him under most circumstances to start.

Originally Posted by dunk

Quite possibly. That would open up a whole plethora of other questions about Fraggle's stubborn £#%&!ing tactics and whether we would be far too lightweight though.

I like Hernandez, top lad, loves a goal and works his %@#$&!s off, but I'm long since past hero worship, I have to call it as I see it, and goals or not, United always look weaker as a whole with him in the team, maybe as a result of the tactics, maybe as a result of the application of the tactics or the form/weaknesses in the team, but as it stands, I wouldn't pick him under most circumstances to start.

The tactics have brought the title back. That was the remit for the season - end of story.

Originally Posted by Tumescent Throb

The tactics have brought the title back. That was the remit for the season - end of story.

Exactly. Let's hope they move on somewhat for the forthcoming defence

hernandez would probably have scored just as many, however he wouldnt have the same impact , as RVPs has scored important goals, chelsea ,arsenal, liverpool, city, couldnt see hernandez scoring in all those games