if sir matt sprang out of a bottle

and instead of giving you 3 wishes he gave you three choices..........

1) stay as we are and keep rooney
2) lose rooney and have a 17 year old giggs instead
3) lose rooney and have cantona back (from 93)

Stay as we are and keep rooney.

We havent even seen Rooney is his pomp yet.

1 please. For the reason already said.

option a nqat


who knows how good rooney could be in 5 years?

Rooney is better than giggs is or ever was imo

option number one

Rooney > Cantona

i'd stop drinking and go to bed.

Option A.

But, erm...

Originally Posted by History

Rooney is better than giggs is or ever was imo

No.

All the responses in this thread

(2)


i love rooney but giggs is something else.

Originally Posted by dunk

Option A.

But, erm...


No.

I think sentiments got in the way here.

Originally Posted by History

I think sentiments got in the way here.

It's alright, I forgive you.

I honestly believe that Giggs is a better player now than when he was 10 years ago. I also believe that Cantona was just right place right time. I think Rooney could be one of the best players I've ever seen. So A. I didn't want to say 1 incase people got confused and started posting 2,3,4, I've cum etc

my heart says option C.
my brain says option B.
my balls say option A.

Wonky, is LSD readily available where you are then?

Stay as we are and lose Rooney.

Originally Posted by Handsome Bob

Stay as we are and lose Rooney.

:applause:

Giggs at 17 for me with the new advances in hamstring management to keep him from twanging the £#%&!ers. Love Rooney but Giggs' first 2 seasons he was completely unstoppable. Plus we know when he turns 36 he is still going to be mint wo we get a guaranteed 19 years from him.

(Does he have to grow back the curly curtains though)

Giggs has got better with age... at 17 he was a 'flawed genius' as my dad used to say.

Cantona was a great but at the highest level never really did anything...

So I can't remember the original question but keep Wazza would be my ultimate answer.

Originally Posted by History

Rooney is better than giggs is or ever was imo

Jesus wept

I would have to go with 2, because watching Giggsy in full flight with the ball is still the most breathtaking thing I've ever seen on a football field. Another 20 years of that? Yes £#%&!ing please.