Would Giggs be that bad as the next MUFC manager?

Originally Posted by ryanMUFC

Like the title suggests.
What would the pros and cons be?
Surely he'd be smart enough to get an experienced head alongside him.
Surely he'd look at bringing in players that will fight for the shirt.
The reaction on here is quite possibly a toys out of pram reaction to Pip going to city.

You've made a very persuasive case. Giggs it is.

Originally Posted by ryanMUFC

His career and experience as the most successful british footballer.
His experience and knowledge of the club.
It's obviously a risk, he's not inheriting Messi, Xavi and Iniesta but we could give him a go at building it as he will be there for the long term should he be successful.

With that reasoning, Bobby charlton should have been given the job years ago.

The novice who inherited messi, Xavi and iniesta, the novice everyone uses to support the idea of Giggs, was successful and didn't stay for the long term.

Originally Posted by Gruber

This tbh

Keeping Jose would make more sense.

Originally Posted by Sparky***

.#
pros - £#%&! off

cons - £#%&! off

£#%&! off

Brah 👍

Originally Posted by Jammy Dodger

Keeping Jose would make more sense.

Doesn't do longevity though, does he?

Originally Posted by Gruber

Doesn't do longevity though, does he?

He didn't want to until he'd experienced and conquered Serie A and La Liga.

Then from 2013 he said wanted to be at English club until his 60s when he would try and do something with the Portugese...

Fergie going for Moyes meant he reluctantly went back to Chelsea and while United have used the last 3 years to £#%&! themselves in every department and will take a lot more work, Mourinho's singular disaster and subsequent sacking means we have one last chance at the obvious. Will the club take it though..?

'He knows the club' people keep saying.

Why is this a thing? So he knows where the biscuits are kept in the canteen
already and we don't have to give him any new training kit. Nice one,
give him the job then.

Means absolutely £#%&! all in the grand scheme of things.

I love Giggs, but now isn't the time to blood a novice, we are so deep in the mire, only the best can get us out of it. He's waiting patiently and the future of our great club is in the balance, without him we could carry on being the next Liverpool, with him, we could be back at the top fairly quickly. Nothing's certain in football, but looking at percentages, Mourhino is a winner of the biggest trophies, Giggs has no experience and is a huge risk.

He's got the job....

More of a question of "Will he be that bad" as opposed to "would be that bad"

Personally I think he'll be giving the sack after 3 months. He already said those 4 matches gave him sleepless nights. Also said he got scared doing his coaching badges.

Great player. One of my football heroes but.....we're done if he gets the job

Said it before, had Giggs taken over (temp or not) after Norwich or even Stoke we would easily be in the top 4 now.

That said I would be more pissed off if Giggs takes over in the summer than i would if LvG ended up staying.

Get Mourinho in the summer and the good times are back 100%.

Originally Posted by Jammy Dodger

You've made a very persuasive case. Giggs it is.

I don't need to make a case for him. The club might if they appoint him..

Mixed feelings

We are a joke as it stands. How bad do we want to rise to the top again?

Yes.

The club needs to get him out of its system though, so give it him now.

Originally Posted by Venceremos

He didn't want to until he'd experienced and conquered Serie A and La Liga.

Then from 2013 he said wanted to be at English club until his 60s when he would try and do something with the Portugese...

Fergie going for Moyes meant he reluctantly went back to Chelsea and while United have used the last 3 years to £#%&! themselves in every department and will take a lot more work, Mourinho's singular disaster and subsequent sacking means we have one last chance at the obvious. Will the club take it though..?

You are so full of £#%&!ing shit

£#%&!ing madridista :£#%&!er:

been said before but he needs managerial experience before taking us over. if moyes and van gaal who have been in the manager game for donkeys turned out to be utter disasters, it doesn't bear thinking about how bad we will be under him.

Klopp, Guardiola and Conte in the league next year, they won't give a shit if Giggs takes over. They WILL give a shit if Mourinho takes over.