Kompany red overturned

Originally Posted by thenorthwillriseagain

he got the ball

Which, by itself, means nothing.

Originally Posted by thenorthwillriseagain

he got the ball

Would you say that if he picked it up?

Rules are rules. Should not be overturned.

Originally Posted by reem

Would you say that if he picked it up?

Rules are rules. Should not be overturned.

Yup. Getting the ball means nothing. Been plenty sent off who got the ball cleanly and didn't have their cards overturned. They cite leaving the ground with both feet as dangerous play, ban it, then overturn a red card for someone who was sent off for the very offence

Clear as £#%&!ing mud.

Originally Posted by red in cumbria

Which, by itself, means nothing.

Originally Posted by reem

Would you say that if he picked it up?

Rules are rules. Should not be overturned.

which means it's open to debate

Originally Posted by thenorthwillriseagain

which means it's open to debate

Which, in turn, means that it shouldn't have been overruled.

Originally Posted by utd99

They should never overturn a decision made on the spot by a referee unless it's blatant, black and white. The alternative is Monday morning refereeing. Where does it end?

Call me a traditionalist, but mid-day Monday for me every time. If it ain't broke don't fix it

Originally Posted by Tumescent Throb

Call me a traditionalist, but mid-day Monday for me every time. If it ain't broke don't fix it

So you agree then? Good, that means a lot.

Case closed.

Originally Posted by Dunne's Half-Time Pint

Are Wilshire's boots on fire??

Originally Posted by Dunne's Half-Time Pint

Good tackle imo

Wiltshite lost control of the ball, Kompany gets there first.

Originally Posted by Dunne's Half-Time Pint

Looking at the last angle on this clip, I suppose he's gone in recklessly but landed his feet in a not-so-dangerous position.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TW_tPXHxjLo

I'll let it slide.

If he'd seriously injured Wilshere you can guarantee he wouldn't have got away with it.

The square-headed mercenary is a £#%&!ing shithouse. Won the ball by putting his opponent off with the threat of a leg breaker. I utterly despise him tbh. Shame Wilshere didn't plant his studs in his ugly face.

Shocking 'challenge' that should have carried a proper ban.

Originally Posted by utd99

They should never overturn a decision made on the spot by a referee unless it's blatant, black and white. The alternative is Monday morning refereeing. Where does it end?

Monday lunch?

Originally Posted by tatty

Monday lunch?

Originally Posted by Alan

If he'd seriously injured Wilshere you can guarantee he wouldn't have got away with it.

The square-headed mercenary is a £#%&!ing shithouse. Won the ball by putting his opponent off with the threat of a leg breaker. I utterly despise him tbh. Shame Wilshere didn't plant his studs in his ugly face.

Shocking 'challenge' that should have carried a proper ban.

I like a lot of your posts but unfortunately this one is utter crap. Neither there was malice in the tackle nor was there any chance of injury to wilshere due to the tackle.

Dean was trying to even it up and that was the only reason he gave a red card to that.

Originally Posted by Dunne's Half-Time Pint

Two frames back shows both feet off the ground. He did pull one back as we can see, but it remains that he left the ground with both feet and threw himself into the tackle. Not that surprising that he was sent off.

Still not a red card for me, but pics like this meant to show it was a perfectly ordinary tackle are disingenuous.

like £#%&! theyd have overturned that if City were 7 points clear and not us

#scousebutIbelieveit

This red card was appealed and rejected.

http://youtu.be/KqUQ5Ct9ViM

The Premier League is an unjust cesspit of corruption and is run by Freemasons and members of the Illuminati. It's much, much better to be in the Endsleigh League where men are men and Arsenal are not allowed to be in it.

Didn't need to see Phil Thompson's sex face. Thanks Duaners.

Kompany's was miles worse than that