Shite United XI

Andy Goram (WTF was SAF thinking)
May - Prunier - Rio (he's in my best but he's a @#%&!) - Sylvester

Cant thiunk????

Originally Posted by believe

Andy Goram (WTF was SAF thinking)
May - Prunier - Rio (he's in my best but he's a @#%&!) - Sylvester

Cant thiunk????

See, I'd have May in the average squad. He was ok, not great, but decent and had that spell in 97 when he scored against Porto and there were calls for an England call up.

In fact, David May should be in the best XI and I'm not negotiable on this.

Originally Posted by The Return of JC

See, I'd have May in the average squad. He was ok, not great, but decent and had that spell in 97 when he scored against Porto and there were calls for an England call up.

In fact, David May should be in the best XI and I'm not negotiable on this.

At right back though? Sense my positioning.

May was class. I think we had a lad named robbins in midfield, bellion ont wing, Kleberson in the mids also. Diego up front? Clayton blackmore?

Originally Posted by believe

Andy Goram (WTF was SAF thinking)
May - Prunier - Rio (he's in my best but he's a @#%&!) - Sylvester

Cant thiunk????

Surely you can't count players who only played a couple of games. Goram was brought in for a specific reason as we needed cover at the time - played 2 games perhaps. Was past his best certainly but was free and was still a better keeper than Leighton at his best. Taibi cost £5m remember. Prunier only played 2 games as well and was only on trial really in an emergency.

Originally Posted by BryanRobson'sLiver

May was class. I think we had a lad named robbins in midfield, bellion ont wing, Kleberson in the mids also. Diego up front? Clayton blackmore?

average XI surely.

Originally Posted by wee man

Surely you can't count players who only played a couple of games. Goram was brought in for a specific reason as we needed cover at the time - played 2 games perhaps. Was past his best certainly but was free and was still a better keeper than Leighton at his best. Taibi cost £5m remember. Prunier only played 2 games as well and was only on trial really in an emergency.

good point

Saha

Originally Posted by Barca '91

Saha

Thats a completely new thread "Injury Prone @#%&!s XI"

Taibi
O'Shea
Prunier
Blackmore
?
Webb
Kleberson
Chadwick
?
Forlan
Bellion

Djemba-Djemba surely?

Prunier? Played two games had one good one and a shitter when he was on loan.
Rio? That's just stupid even if you think he's a @#%&!
May? Certainley not the best but £#%&! me another stupid choice
Silvestre? Too £#%&!ing right Could be a very good player if he wasn't a simpleton.


I think the fact that people still roll Prunier's name out when naming these 11's is a testament to the fact that fergie isn't an inept £#%&!tard in the transfer market as some would have you believe.

Paddy Roche
Colin Gibson
William Prunier
Graeme Hogg
Jon Sivabaek (sp)
Ralph Milne
Kleberson
Mike Phelan
Darren Ferguson
Scott McGarvey
Dion Dublin

Originally Posted by Crumps

Prunier? Played two games had one good one and a shitter when he was on loan.
Rio? That's just stupid even if you think he's a @#%&!
May? Certainley not the best but £#%&! me another stupid choice
Silvestre? Too £#%&!ing right Could be a very good player if he wasn't a simpleton.


I think the fact that people still roll Prunier's name out when naming these 11's is a testament to the fact that fergie isn't an inept £#%&!tard in the transfer market as some would have you believe.

So Prunier was shite for 50% of his United career.
May at Right Back!!!!
Rio - don't start me. He's the best but he's a @#%&! so he makes it.
Sylvester - NFT.

Roche
Sivebeck
Hogg
Higgins
P Neville
Fletcher
Milne
Sloan
Greening
Birtles
Scott McGarvey

Originally Posted by withapacketofsweets

Roche
Sivebeck
Hogg
Higgins
P Neville
Fletcher
Milne
Sloan
Greening
Birtles
Scott McGarvey

I thought John Sievebeck was a great player.

Originally Posted by Amish Mash

Paddy Roche
Colin Gibson
William Prunier
Graeme Hogg
Jon Sivabaek (sp)
Ralph Milne
Kleberson
Mike Phelan
Darren Ferguson
Scott McGarvey
Dion Dublin

That is just £#%&!ing scary

Kleberson shouldn't be in there, though; he was far better than he ended up looking. United came too early for him, but he was a superb player.

Originally Posted by Tumescent Throb

That is just £#%&!ing scary

Kleberson shouldn't be in there, though; he was far better than he ended up looking. United came too early for him, but he was a superb player.

But this was a shite United XI and he was shite for us. Not done much since as well but agree that he did look half-decent before he came to us.

Originally Posted by Amish Mash

But this was a shite United XI and he was shite for us. Not done much since as well but agree that he did look half-decent before he came to us.

Had a few games where he looked like a player for us in the early days I reckon. Anyway, from recent times I'd swap him for Djemba - even though he had a similar time of it in Keane's shadow.

Overall though, if your XI walked out on a Saturday I wouldn't know whether to laugh or cry

Jim F Leighton
Tommy F Jackson
Mark F Higgins
Ian F Ure
Colin F Gibson
Liam F Miller
Luke F Chadwick
Ralph F Milne
F Kleberson
Alan F Brazil
Terry F Gibson