Scholes

3 game ban will do him good imo he needed a rest, though not sure who takes his place now, fletcher?.

Giggs.

But he won't

Originally Posted by Lou_Macari_Chippy

3 game ban will do him good imo he needed a rest, though not sure who takes his place now, fletcher?.

Unfortunately, Fletcher is injured.

O'Shea will probably come in.

Originally Posted by Lou_Macari_Chippy

3 game ban will do him good imo he needed a rest, though not sure who takes his place now, fletcher?.

I don't agree with everything you say, but you are right.

Originally Posted by Fatboy Shrek

I don't agree with everything you say, but you are right

But you do seem to be saying that a bit more these days

Giggs moves inside, then Park on the wing.

Or he'll just bring in Ireland's No.1 as a straight swap.

Can we confirm something? -

Did Scholes actually take a swing at the lad or was it one of those sort of arm swinging gestures to the ref to blow for a foul?

O'Shea or Giggs would be my guess....Park on the wing??

We're £#%&!ed if Rooney's out for a while though.
I know he didn't play that well today (although not as bad as some of the anti-Rooney #@&%!s on RedIsh would have you believe)...but we're very thin on the ground striker wise.


We really are lacking depth where creativity is concerned...& that might cost us in 'ten men behind the ball' games at Old Trafford - especially the 3 'bogey' games - Boro', Bolton & Blackburn.
Carrick has to really step up to the plate in those games (I thought he played well today actually)

Unfortunately he swung at that snidey scouse bastard imo

Originally Posted by Lou_Macari_Chippy

Can we confirm something -

Did Scholes actually take a swing at the lad or was it one of those sort of arm swinging gestures to the ref to blow for a foul?

He deffo had a swing for him to be honest

Originally Posted by Lou_Macari_Chippy

Can we confirm something? -

Did Scholes actually take a swing at the lad or was it one of those sort of arm swinging gestures to the ref to blow for a foul?

He swung at him IMO. Only problem was he didn't connect.

Originally Posted by Coracao

He deffo had a swing for him to be honest

Thats a shame, thought there might be a shout for appeal. From tv it was a little bit hard to tell, probably get no joy out of the f.a even if that was the case though.

Scholes took a swing, unfortuately he missed.

Giggs will move into the centre with Park out wide, should be good enough to be bolton and blackburn at home.

Originally Posted by Lou_Macari_Chippy

Thats a shame, thought there might be a shout for appeal. From tv it was a little bit hard to tell, probably get no joy out of the f.a even if that was the case though.

Not sure what Tv you were watching!!!

Earlier I was saying it was at the ref. It looks a bit like that at normal speed but in slo-mo it looks like he slapped(!) out.

Originally Posted by Lou_Macari_Chippy

Thats a shame, thought there might be a shout for appeal. From tv it was a little bit hard to tell, probably get no joy out of the f.a even if that was the case though.

There will be no appeal.

I'd love to think he meant it!...good job he didn't connect though or the press would have forced the FA to ban him for 10 matches.

Pic inconclusive!
http://picsrv.manutd.com/?fif=/manu/...70732&cvt=jpeg

Originally Posted by Fatboy Shrek

He swung at him IMO. Only problem was he didn't connect.

May as well be hanged as a sheep than a lamb.

Originally Posted by armchair

Earlier I was saying it was at the ref. It looks a bit like that at normal speed but in slo-mo it looks like he slapped(!) out.

thats what made me think it was a gesture - open palm rather than a closed fist. I think if he wanted to hit him he could have done but like i say angle was not good (fox sports).

fergie said the ref was right, he had to send him off