Who is the best United player ever?

Originally Posted by Neo

Sir Bobby Charlton.

Youth team product, Busby Babe, club captain, European Cup winner, World Cup winner, Ballon d'Or winner, club's all-time highest goalscorer.

Sir Bobby is the greatest United player of all time IMO. NQAT.

Originally Posted by no fun

What a £#%&!ing joke

It's not even worth discussing

The answer is George best

Now carry on debating who's second

Despite all his trickery, Best wouldn´t have got past Edwards

Would have loved to have seen Best, Law and Charlton in their pomp.

My old fella reckons Georgie is the best player he's seen, apart from Maradona - so I'll take his word for it.

Wayne Rooney

Surely between Ronaldo, Best, Charlton and Robson



Awful thread.

Giuliano Maiorana

Schmeichel ffs

Cantona

Originally Posted by bigMikeA

Surely between Ronaldo, Best, Charlton and Robson



Awful thread.

I'd have Keane ahead of Robson fwiw

Bobby Charlton.

Although the best I've ever seen is Cantona.

Originally Posted by carlosartorial

Bobby Charlton.

Although the best I've ever seen is Cantona.

Saw my first game in 1967

George is the best I have seen

Only player that comes close is Ronaldo

Favourite player is denis

Originally Posted by Harri Jaffa

*Insert inevitable article about Duncan Edwards from July 2004*

Wasn't he the old Phil Jones?

From the players I've seen it's got to be Ronaldo. Eric was incredible, Schmeichel unbeatable and Giggs lasted forever but Ronaldo was truly special.

George Best might have been better but he was well before my time. Whilst I appreciate he was clearly a great, I've always wondered if time and his off field issues make people overstate his abilities.

Giggs was a marvellous tackler who could play full back, midfield and of course on the wing.

He had the ability to score that goal against Arsenal, never bottled penalties...

Remind me why Ronaldo is better?

Originally Posted by Lok

Wasn't he the old Phil Jones?

From the players I've seen it's got to be Ronaldo. Eric was incredible, Schmeichel unbeatable and Giggs lasted forever but Ronaldo was truly special.

George Best might have been better but he was well before my time. Whilst I appreciate he was clearly a great, I've always wondered if time and his off field issues make people overstate his abilities.

Ronaldo was better than George. Bestie had trickery and that was his strength. Ronaldo has trickery too, but so much more.

Veevoh
Nqat

No honorable mention for Scholes? He could hit a man having a piss from 150 yards away.

Originally Posted by Switching Off

No honorable mention for Scholes? He could hit a man having a piss from 150 yards away.

Had the question been - "United´s best ever impact player" then I would have gone for Scholesy

Originally Posted by ashtonred

Ronaldo was better than George. Bestie had trickery and that was his strength. Ronaldo has trickery too, but so much more.

Go on...

Originally Posted by Cream

Go on...

Jeez, shouldn´t need me to tell you. Do you watch football?

Originally Posted by Cream

Giggs was a marvellous tackler who could play full back, midfield and of course on the wing.

He had the ability to score that goal against Arsenal, never bottled penalties...

Remind me why Ronaldo is better?

Shut up, reem you £#%&!ing weapon, so you are.