Who is worst - Nani, Anderson, Carrick or Hargreaves?

http://www.est1892.co.uk/forums/showthread.php?t=55996

The Scousers will decide. Some superb, well thought out arguments there.

He is pound for pound, one of the best holding players in Europe

What the £#%&! does that even mean?

Just shows what we are competing against when these clowns are spending stupid money on average squad players and only getting about half of them right



How many 'squad' players has benitez bought and theyve done nothing?These idiots are £#%&!ing clueless.

All 4 scored in CL final shoot out victory. NFT

They're tearing each other up defending us

How any of them can say Nani and Andersen are crap is beyond me. Anderson has repeatedly torn Saint Steven to pieces when he's played them. And last season Nani scored one and set one up against them in a 3-0 win

Definitely Carrick, he's £#%&!ing shite

Originally Posted by Zorg

What the £#%&! does that even mean?

I think they are suggesting that lb for £ he is one of the best holding players in europe.

Suggesting he is fat.

Originally Posted by Zorg

What the £#%&! does that even mean?

Originally Posted by Stakker

I think they are suggesting that lb for £ he is one of the best holding players in europe.

Suggesting he is fat.

I think they mean that he is alright against anyone his own size or smaller, but is £#%&!ed when put up against someone bigger and heavier than him. Given that he is 5'6'' and 10 stone wet through, that would mean he is shit 90% of the time.

Strangely for every rabidly stupid @#%&! on there seems to be one that knows a bit about football.

I find it very difficult to argue with this one

i disagree, whilst the price may have been excessive for two 'potential' players, if they come good and play for utd for many years to come the fee will be obsolete. anderson is only 20 and nani 21, both are full internationals and have very good resale value, so its not like they will lose money if they eventually decide to sell.

nani at £14 mil has played a role for the mancs similar to babel who cost £11 mil and i wouldnt say he has fared much better. anderson at 18 mil has done much better than our £6 mil brazilian lucas and whilst the price margin between the two is massive i still think anderson has the potential to be a mainstay in the utd line up for years to come, lucas on the other hand....

Thing is, no one knows the detials for sure of how much we have paid so far or will pay in total for either player do they?

Nani.

Originally Posted by Fuzzy Dunlop

Nani.

poo off

Fletcher and Park.Those are the guys who have performed for them

Originally Posted by Fuzzy Dunlop

Nani.

Agreed

Originally Posted by Part 36 Offer

poo off

Sorry only seen the subject post now

It's still Nani though.

Originally Posted by Harri Jaffa

Agreed

Shouldn't you be off helping TSV find his car.

Originally Posted by Fuzzy Dunlop

Sorry only seen the subject post now

It's still Nani though.

you little wretch Dunners, Why I oughta...

The whole of Merseyside should be £#%&!ing napalmed.

Originally Posted by The Watcher

The whole of Merseyside should be £#%&!ing napalmed.

I thought it already had been.

Requires registration to view.