scholes and giggs...

great halfs from both of them.

both doing more damage than good.

scholes is playing carricks role and whilst playing it very shit, he isnt actually allowing us to make some sort of advantage out of a third man in midfield.
i rather have lampard tbh as at least he knows his job as the third man in midfield.

giggs is simply embarassing and touched the ball about 3 times..



but then again giggs has so man medals and appearances while scholes doesnt have an agent so they should be playing.

it will take until about january for some to see how much damage those two are doing our team.

They got away with it last year when Rooney and Ronnie rescued us, I have said it a few times, Giggs and Scholes were not as good as people made out last season. Scholes just wastes our 3 man midfield advantage. I would even play Rooney as the 3rd midfielder when he is fit, at least he would play more urgently and get into the box more.

there's £#%&! all wrong with our midfield that wouldn't be sorted by a couple of proper strikers ahead of them to use

Giggs to be fair is not having a great game thus far.

Scholesy teh same but he is out of position imho.

Carrick Hargreaves

Ronaldo Rooney Tevez

Saha

we're toothless in attack

Originally Posted by Darth Vidic

Carrick Hargreaves

Ronaldo Rooney Tevez

Saha

exactly but unfortunately 3 of that 4 are unavailable


and scholes is the midfielder we have that is most likely to score a goal.

Vio and One Love, who should be playing instead of Giggs and Scholes today?

Originally Posted by Flowers of Manchester

Giggs to be fair is not having a great game thus far.

Scholesy teh same but he is out of position imho.

giggs hasnt done anything good this season tbh.

scholes is out of position because our midfield is carrying him through the game at the teams and carricks expense.

he is the third man in midfield. the midfielder who cant run or tackle at the moment. he should be futhest up the pitch supporting tevez and having shots from in or around the box yet he is picking the ball up and trying to pass it when carrick should really have the ball and should be passing it to him just outside the "D"

http://www.utdforum.com/showpost.php...28&postcount=8

Originally Posted by Fatboy Shrek

Vio and One Love, who should be playing instead of Giggs and Scholes today?

easy.

any striker on the books and eagles.

some urgency and pace.

id rather see us play 2 strikers at scholes expense.

meaning that carrick and hargreaves play CM.

we dont need the three players in midfield.


its also my opinion ronaldo wouldnt have been so frustrated against portsmouth if we were not carrying scholes and giggs through the season.

tevez is playing a midfield role too, it may help if he stayed up there, but being a main striker isn't is game.

it's all square pegs in round holes at the moment, enforced if we are going to use these players

so carrick is playing lets say not his best, because of scholes? hargreaves seems to be doing ok, is that cos of scholes too?


scholes and hargreaves for me if you want two midfielders that should be there

lose scholes and you lose a more likely goalscorer than either of the other 2

Originally Posted by violater

easy.

any striker on the books and eagles.

So Dong and Eagles, perhaps?

Championship players.

and vio would be the first to slag off some young kid who would fail to make an impact up front in a pre game in front of 75,000

Originally Posted by chorleyred

there's £#%&! all wrong with our midfield that wouldn't be sorted by a couple of proper strikers ahead of them to use

Exactly.

Originally Posted by violater

easy.

eagles.

some urgency and pace.

£#%&! me that's funny!

easy.

any striker on the books and eagles.

Why would you say Eagles ahead of someone like Martin

Originally Posted by violater

great halfs from both of them.

both doing more damage than good.

scholes is playing carricks role and whilst playing it very shit, he isnt actually allowing us to make some sort of advantage out of a third man in midfield.
i rather have lampard tbh as at least he knows his job as the third man in midfield.

giggs is simply embarassing and touched the ball about 3 times..



but then again giggs has so man medals and appearances while scholes doesnt have an agent so they should be playing.

it will take until about january for some to see how much damage those two are doing our team.

What the £#%&! is a man medal?

You £#%&!ing whopper