Buttner

they're both horrific options.

Originally Posted by That Boy Ronaldo!

Got caught sleeping at Cisse's goal last night.

So let's not play a player who shows great potential, and is good going forward but will make mistakes and is inexperienced for a player who is proven to make mistakes and offer less in either direction because he has experience.

Froggleson logic that is right there.

Originally Posted by The Return of JC

His doesn't play like he has experience. Full of schoolboy errors.

That may be so, but we know how much stock Fagie puts in experience. With a constantly changing defence at the moment, even stretching to the keeper, I'm sure he'll keep Evra as first choice for the time being.

Originally Posted by Argentina

So let's not play a player who shows great potential, and is good going forward but will make mistakes and is inexperienced for a player who is proven to make mistakes and offer less in either direction because he has experience.

Froggleson logic that is right there.

Psychology 101, 70 year old manager values experience over things like pace, verve and dynamism.

Love 'em both, tbh but Fabio > Buttner and Evra.
I hope he comes back next year, and if not at left back then further up the pitch.
Fabio > Buttner, Evra and Nani and anyone else on the left.

Originally Posted by BarryX

Love 'em both, tbh but Fabio > Buttner and Evra.
.

Originally Posted by John Blazini

That may be so, but we know how much stock Fagie puts in experience. With a constantly changing defence at the moment, even stretching to the keeper, I'm sure he'll keep Evra as first choice for the time being.

Don't disagree with that. Im sure he will. Whether he should be is a different matter.

Originally Posted by Fuzzy Dunlop

tbf he did disclaimer it by saying in a different position

Frogson in playing safe with older player shocker

Evra all day long at the moment for me. Buttner may be good enough to take over but... Fabio and Brady down that side for me asap

with Young and Buttenr as competition

£5m for Evra in the summer

Originally Posted by Harri Jaffa

Do you think Evra would have played as well in those games?

To me Buttner looks like Evra used to

This.....

Butters looks proud as £#%&! to playing for United, looks like he would run through a wall for United and take out any £#%&!er that gets in his way.

Looks like he may score a few more than Evra has during his time

really hoep Buttner starts on Saturday after Evra's holocaust revisited display last Sunday:shakehead:

buttner's looked great so far, two easy games tbf. that said, him and rafael down the flanks guarantees all sorts of fun so i'm all for it. them two providing width, a narrower midfield like the one we saw last night (one sitting, two ahead) and three up top and we're looking proper entertaining again.

ddg
rafael - rio - evans - buttner
fletcher
valencia - cleverley
kagawa
rvp - rooney

:mmmonkey:

lots of alternatives - carrick for fletcher, the fat @#%&! for cleverley, cleverley for kagawa, loads of strikers... nani, welbeck, cheech, scholes off the bench as game-changers...

Originally Posted by borsuk

buttner's looked great so far, two easy games tbf. that said, him and rafael down the flanks guarantees all sorts of fun so i'm all for it. them two providing width, a narrower midfield like the one we saw last night (one sitting, two ahead) and three up top and we're looking proper entertaining again.

ddg
rafael - rio - evans - buttner
fletcher
valencia - cleverley
kagawa
rvp - rooney

:mmmonkey:

lots of alternatives - carrick for fletcher, the fat @#%&! for cleverley, cleverley for kagawa, loads of strikers... nani, welbeck, cheech, scholes off the bench as game-changers...

great team but no way could we ever start without Carrick he's our main man in mdifield so swap him for Fletcher and it's a goer

Originally Posted by borsuk

DdG
Rafael - Rio - Evans - Buttner
Carrick
Anderson - Cleverley
Kagawa
RvP - Rooney

Fixed it for you.

Originally Posted by dunk

ruined it for you.

aye

Originally Posted by borsuk

aye

Valencia is injured mon ami, Anderson isn't for once.

Fletcher can't play twice in a week.

My team could play Saturday

Originally Posted by dunk

Fixed it for you.

Would like to see that tbh.

Phelan/Rene out, dunk in

Originally Posted by dunk

Valencia is injured mon ami, Anderson isn't for once.

Fletcher can't play twice in a week.

My team could play Saturday

:chunnerchunnerchunner:

Originally Posted by borsuk

:chunnerchunnerchunner: