Worst keeper

#@&%!ed it up first time

Bosnich for me - couldn't even kick a ball.

Even at 7 years I old I could detect Leighton was an utter clean sheet danger

Expected him to be 7 foot tall, only 6ft 1

Bosnich, couldnt kick it out of his area - he was laughably bad

The Leighton Condom.

NF&T.

P4P we all know who it is……

some of those were signed as no2 etc

Honestly lads, paddy roache was the best Irish joke of the 1970s

Originally Posted by no fun

Honestly lads, paddy roache was the best Irish joke of the 1970s

Apparently the Catholic church banned him from being a godparent.

Bosnich just gets it for me once you have added in the dislikeability (is that a word?) factor.

Taibi?

Bosnich awful, Barthez terrible. Roy Carroll was the worst for me.

https://youtu.be/CXL-YOlsDqw?si=azy43JAiJmLVQCMb

Originally Posted by magic_cantona

Taibi?

Bosnich awful, Barthez terrible. Roy Carroll was the worst for me.

Didn’t he have a decent run in the 2004 fa cup win?

Goram?

Was Leighton really worse than this current clown? I was around at the time, and don't think so. Easily could be wrong though.

Originally Posted by TheNew

Goram?

Was Leighton really worse than this current clown? I was around at the time, and don't think so. Easily could be wrong though.

Leighton made some big errors in his last 12 months but I thought he was good for his first few years.

Originally Posted by suedeshoes

Leighton made some big errors in his last 12 months but I thought he was good for his first few years.

I can only recall 2 games when he was really shocking…the 5-1 at Maine rd and the 3-3 final v palace

My old man despised Paddy Roche. Don’t remember enough myself of him playing though, so Bosnich for me.

Tbf to Barthez, he made one of the greatest saves I've ever seen in the shirt.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lZml5oa-h_U

From what people I know who were old enough to remember Roache said, he's head and shoulders above any other United keeper for shitness in the last 50 years.

Originally Posted by Neo

Tbf to Barthez, he made one of the greatest saves I've ever seen in the shirt.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lZml5oa-h_U

Also had two PL winners medals and a world Cup under his belt.

I really don't think I've seen anyone worse in the shirt than Onana. Old man reckons Roche was a disgrace though.

Leighton was bad. Got dog's abuse from Redissue. Seemed to be constantly in no man's land. Barthez also really poor and positionally unreliable. Though gets a very easy ride on here, de Gea last year was probably the worst i can recall (golden glove notwithstanding!), not least in gifting a goal in the first ever all-Manchester cup final the utter #@&%!

Bosnich was woeful so i’ve voted for him.

It’s Onana thus far though.

Bosnich for me. Taibi and Goram did not play enough - and rightly so. Jimmy Rimmer should be nowhere near this list - deputised well for Stepney and was given a European Cup medal, then won another with Villa.