Worst keeper

Of those I've seen, Leighton.

He was a total liability and taking that bold step of binning him was a key moment on the way to success for Frogger. Most managers would have taken the easy decision, kept him in and possibly lost the replay.

A little positivity - by no means the best keeper but by far my favourite (sorry, Edwin) is the late, great Mad Les Sealey. Love the guy. If you get a chance, I recommend his rescued autobiography.

Originally Posted by Rorschach

A little positivity - by no means the best keeper but by far my favourite (sorry, Edwin) is the late, great Mad Les Sealey. Love the guy. If you get a chance, I recommend his rescued autobiography.

What a man. You'd never put him at the top ability wise but his sheer presence and personality made up for it and spread confidence throughout the team. Brilliant guy.

Originally Posted by Neo

Tbf to Barthez, he made one of the greatest saves I've ever seen in the shirt.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lZml5oa-h_U

A United supporting mate of mine gave him absolutely no credit for that because he hated him so much.

"It only looked good because he's small"

Onana or Paddy Roche. Probably Onana.

Originally Posted by magic_cantona

Taibi?

Bosnich awful, Barthez terrible. Roy Carroll was the worst for me.

Carroll gets a bad rep for some reason. Seem to remember him playing a couple of games vs Arsenal at the height of the rivalry and didn't let us down. Not a chance I'd be confident of Onana doing the same

I think Carroll gets a bad rep because people immediately think of that £#%&! up versus Spurs. But you’re right, he was generally pretty solid as far as I can remember.

Onana for me. I’ve never seen anyone flap so much when a ball goes into the box. He’s shit. His shot-stopping is below average and that’s being extremely generous.

I feel sorry for him because he seems a decent guy.

Originally Posted by Ethers

I think Carroll gets a bad rep because people immediately think of that £#%&! up versus Spurs. But you’re right, he was generally pretty solid as far as I can remember.

Onana for me. I’ve never seen anyone flap so much when a ball goes into the box. He’s shit. His shot-stopping is below average and that’s being extremely generous.

I feel sorry for him because he seems a decent guy.

Certainly a better keeper for Utd than the likes of Bosnich, PIG, Taibi, Foster...and probably quite a few more.

Originally Posted by Medlock

Leighton was bad. Got dog's abuse from Redissue. Seemed to be constantly in no man's land. Barthez also really poor and positionally unreliable. Though gets a very easy ride on here, de Gea last year was probably the worst i can recall (golden glove notwithstanding!), not least in gifting a goal in the first ever all-Manchester cup final the utter #@&%!

Captain Condom

Originally Posted by Ethers

I think Carroll gets a bad rep because people immediately think of that £#%&! up versus Spurs. But you’re right, he was generally pretty solid as far as I can remember.

Onana for me. I’ve never seen anyone flap so much when a ball goes into the box. He’s shit. His shot-stopping is below average and that’s being extremely generous.

I feel sorry for him because he seems a decent guy.

Milan at home is my worst memory of him.

John O’Shea