3 nominations for PFA player of the year

Scholes, Giggs and Ronaldo have all been nominated for the main award
Roo and Ron for the young player award

Gerrard and Fabregas have been nominated for the main award, £#%&! knows how.

Originally Posted by rhodzy

Scholes, Giggs and Ronaldo have all been nominated for the main award
Roo and Ron for the young player award

Gerrard and Fabregas have been nominated for the main award, £#%&! knows how.

1 goal fabregas

Giggs for the main award? Quite surprised at that. Evra would be a better nomination.

Originally Posted by TreeFiddy

Giggs for the main award? Quite surprised at that. Evra would be a better nomination.

are you taking the piss? giggs has been our 2nd best player this season.

Originally Posted by dakpul

are you taking the piss? giggs has been our 2nd best player this season.

agree with that, although his form has dropped off a little, he's been fantastic in the whole. Certainly more effective than Scholes imo.

Originally Posted by dakpul

are you taking the piss? giggs has been our 2nd best player this season.

Agreed, shite the last weeks maybe but worked his #@&%! off all season

Originally Posted by dakpul

are you taking the piss? giggs has been our 2nd best player this season.

Our 3 best players this season have been

Ronnie
Scholes
Evra

I'd put Giggs fourth.

Relax. I'm not saying he hasn't been class, I just think others have been slightly better.

Fabregas? Words fail me.

Originally Posted by TreeFiddy

Our 3 best players this season have been

Ronnie
Scholes
Evra

I'd put Giggs fourth.

Relax. I'm not saying he hasn't been class, I just think others have been slightly better.

Carrick?

If we all agree that Ronaldo has been the main man, I'd say Carrick has been as important and consistent as anyone else this season.

Stevie 'G' to win. Don't fight it lads.

What about Nemanja? He's been inspirational this season!

Giggs can be frustrating at times, during games, but you could never leave him out.

He tries flicks, one-twos and other passes that 8 times out of 10 don't come off but then he'll produce a couple excellent moves that will either result in a goal or a definite goal opportunity.

Originally Posted by The Return of JC

Carrick?

If we all agree that Ronaldo has been the main man, I'd say Carrick has been as important and consistent as anyone else this season.

Wouldn't agree with Evra being in the top 3. Been out for a few months. Carrick, Ronaldo, Giggs.
If this had been a few months ago Scholes and Vidic would have been in there but they've dropped off a little recently

Essien should've been in there in place of Fabregas. Berbatov in place of Gerrard.

I agree that Essien and Berbatov should be there.

have all been superb so far.



The fact that the first two have had the occasional iffy game or spell notwithstanding.



Applying the same disclaimer, Rio Ferdinand deserves a nod ahead of either Gerrard or Fabregas.

Originally Posted by koppas

Essien should've been in there in place of Fabregas. Berbatov in place of Gerrard.

I concur.

Originally Posted by TreeFiddy

I agree that Essien and Berbatov should be there.

Indeed, most definitely worthy of a place.

Rio Ferdinand deserves a nod ahead of either Gerrard or Fabregas

Seems like Vidic has brought the best out of Rio & it's a real partnership rather than an individual thing (i.e. rat eater Carragher holding the Vermin together). Rio's just done what he's supposed to & defended well & scored a cracker against the Dippers.

Fabregas is class, loads of assists & dictates the way they play from the centre of the park, as opposed to Stevie 'hoof & run real quick' Gerrard. I don't think you can ask more of a 19 year old to be honest, not in his position in that powder puff team. He walked through our midfield earlier this year.

Essien should be there instead of Gerrard, I'd agree with that.

I really don't see why Gerrard is there, if they're going on reputation then they should stick Henry in there again.