Who's your all time favourite United player?

Eric has been for a long time, although Anderson will be.

I think now that he's not playing as often Paul Scholes is one of my faves - He's been a class player for us over the last 10 years or so.

Cantona too for obvious reasons and Robbo for what he did in the mediocre 80's...

Robbo, Eric, Sparky and Scholesy all very popular it seems.

Interestingly, not one mention for Giggs as yet.

Giggsy

Originally Posted by Rhodzy

Giggsy

I almost said him actually instead of Scholes. Probably up there.

Originally Posted by poppy

Robbo, Eric, Sparky and Scholesy all very popular it seems.

Interestingly, not one mention for Giggs as yet.

I think Giggsy will get the plaudits when he's gone... For me he's been a great servant but, since about 2001, I've got annoyed with the way he stops playing and complains at the minor contact and sometimes gives up. He's a bit hot and cold and that's how I remember him at the moment.

He would be in my top five.

Roy Keane.

Keane

Followed closely by Eric, Sparky and big Norm.

Can I just add an honourable mention to Steve Bruce.

If Eric was the genius behind our '90s comeback then Bruce was the engine room behind it all.

He embodies what a United player should be. "Crawling over broken glass" etc and is also a decent bloke.

Hate these kind of things!...Can't just narrow it down to one.

As a kid it was always Robbo & Whiteside.

During my late teens/early to mid twenties it was Eric, Scholesy & Ole.

Nowadays it's Rooney.

My 'Retro' favourite has to be the Lawman...Cool as £#%&!!


Honourable mentions for Hughesie & Giggs.

scholes of the current/recent players. but of all time:






enormously underrated by united fans imo. dominated and personified the club through the dark years of the 70s and early 80s. fantastic player.

Originally Posted by borsuk

scholes of the current/recent players. but of all time:






enormously underrated by united fans imo. dominated and personified the club through the dark years of the 70s and early 80s. fantastic player.

After Alan Hansen, probably Scotland's greatest ever defender. Good shout.

Originally Posted by poppy

After Alan Hansen, probably Scotland's greatest ever defender. Good shout.

My old man says Willie Miller was better than Hansen....


That said - he £#%&!ing hates Hansen.

Originally Posted by poppy

After Alan Hansen, probably Scotland's greatest ever defender. Good shout.

hansen wasn't fit to wipe martin buchan's arse.

If you want a player, who has affected United's recent history more than anyone else, I give you.........

Lee Martin

1. Bestie
2 Lawman
3. Eric
4. Sparky
5. Robbo

I think god it's hard, but deffo Georgie 1st.

Keano

[dm]3ttVCxjPy9QJO61Sl[/dm]