The Premier League's most overated player ever?

Originally Posted by NegativeNorris

So who's the most overrated player to play for Utd?

.

Henrik Larrson's time at United is massively overrated. He was good in his first game then he was gash

Originally Posted by itisme_panaflex

O'shea and park were solid players for the club. Never in a million yrs can you accuse them of being over rated.

Squads can not be full of star players. People under-estimate how important that type of player was over the years for Fergie, creating and maintaining the right attitude and winning mentality.

Remember that Fa Cup match against Arsenal when we started with the twins on the wing, and O'Shea and Gibson in midfield? Not the team any of us would have wanted but their attitude and approach was superb. Phil Neville beasting Vieria in midfield another example.

Wasn't Park out for a few months and was just thrown into that City game?

Originally Posted by Clarkie

Wasn't Park out for a few months and was just thrown into that City game?

That was an absolutely disgusting match tbh.
At that point of park's career he could barely run 10 yards before falling over.
Him vs toure before toure couldnt be arsed. It was like a child against an athlete.

Originally Posted by itisme_panaflex

That was an absolutely disgusting match tbh.
At that point of park's career he could barely run 10 yards before falling over.
Him vs toure before toure couldnt be arsed. It was like a child against an athlete.

Hateful night.
I remember the 2nd half, City shitting it and sitting back the entire time, while we had zero fight. Absolutely bottled the whole thing

Originally Posted by itisme_panaflex

Maybe if you asked supporters of another club they may say cantona.

you don't need to ask supporters of another club.

he was a bit like nani.

Originally Posted by Tiberian

You could probably make arguments for Nani in both these categories. Such is Nani.

I was a fan, obviously, between 2010/2012 he was an excellent player for Utd, extremely productive and possibly second only to Bale as a wide player in the country. It is a shame that for the last 3 and 1/2 seasons he was injured/out of favour/out of form at Utd or wasting his ability in Portugal and Turkey. Should have been the prime of his career.

Shame also that he has a brain the size of a pea.

..

Originally Posted by 20 times

Henrik Larrson's time at United is massively overrated. He was good in his first game then he was gash

Didn't he only play about six times anyway?

Ander Herrera.

Originally Posted by Neo

Ander Herrera.

I like him, been shit recently though

Park overrated? Massively underrated. He was a beast in some huge matches for United.

Highlights include:

- completely nullifying Pirlo in 2010
- his Performance against barca at OT in 2008 ( he and tevez were absolute stars that night)
- Chelsea home 3-0 2009 (I particularly remember the forum SEETHE when they saw we'd put out Fletch Park and Giggs against Essien Lampard and ballack and we £#%&!ing mauled them
- banged in huge goals against Arsenal and Chelsea In the CL and generally always seemed to notch against Arsenal.

Sure he wasn't pretty, but he was huge tactical option and more often than not he. Got the job done.

Originally Posted by Stickman

Park overrated? Massively underrated. He was a beast in some huge matches for United.

Highlights include:

- completely nullifying Pirlo in 2010
- his Performance against barca at OT in 2008 ( he and tevez were absolute stars that night)
- Chelsea home 3-0 2009 (I particularly remember the forum SEETHE when they saw we'd put out Fletch Park and Giggs against Essien Lampard and ballack and we £#%&!ing mauled them
- banged in huge goals against Arsenal and Chelsea In the CL and generally always seemed to notch against Arsenal.

Sure he wasn't pretty, but he was huge tactical option and more often than not he. Got the job done.

This - the lad would ´walk´ into today´s team.
Intelligent player.

Originally Posted by ashtonred

This - the lad would ´wok´ into today´s team.
Intelligent player.

Bit racist that tbf.